Summary: Our Sleeping Ninjas don’t mess around when it comes to comfort. Here, you’ll find an unbiased, in-depth pillow top mattress review of the most comfortable mattresses.
Disclosure: Sleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.
Chances are, if you’re shopping for a pillow-top mattress, you’re into luxury. Or, at the very least, you want to feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud and wake up extremely refreshed and rested. The Sleeping Ninjas team feels the same way!
In this pillow top mattress review, we’ll take you through the basics of these luxurious and comfy pieces so you can choose the most suitable mattress.
Table of Contents
Best Pillow Top Mattresses: Our Top Picks
Best Firm Pillow Top Mattress
Highly durable hybrid design that looks and feels like the ultimate pillow top mattress for the finest 5-star hotel.
Save $200 with code NINJA200
Best Luxury Pillow Top
Exquisitely designed with 9 layers of luxurious comfort. Our top pick for the best pillow top mattress.
Save $175 with code NINJA
Best Customizable Pillow Top Mattress
Fully customizable to suit your needs with varying soft or firmness based on your sleeping style. Will not disappoint.
Save $200 with code NINJA200
Best Value Pillow Top Mattress
Euro Top is made of New Zealand wool and organic quilted cotton for a cooling, comfortable sleep.
Save $300 with code NINJA
Best Organic Pillow Top
100% GOTS certified organic materials. Eco-friendly. Excellent cooling functionally. Natural latex and organic cotton pillow top.
Here’s a quick list of our selections in this pillow top mattress review:
Pillow Top Mattress Reviews
Check out the following pillow top mattress reviews and get the perfect one!
Winkbeds – Best Firm Pillow Top Mattress
You can choose the size and firmness of this pillow-top mattress to get the best fit for yourself and your bed. Winkbeds are crafted by hand near the company’s Wisconsin location. The materials are American sourced and the construction is filled with personal care and sincerity that’s rare these days.
Winkbeds offers perfectly-designed hybrid mattress that will satisfy yourself, your partner, or anyone who lies down on it. In short, you have the plushness of the pillow-top along with the support and contouring of an innerspring.
Technical Specs
This mattress is equipped with a gel foam and hypersoft foam blend for a supremely cooling experience. There is also a latex layer for a great bounce factor that responds to some pressure. Its edge support and high-density foams ensure durability.
Pros
- Risk-free trial of 101 nights
- Comfort level is customizable
- Gives contouring as well as pushback support
- Will not heat up during the night
- Breathability and high comfort due to great quality of materials
Cons
- Might be more bouncy than some may like
- Could be uncomfortable if firmness isn’t just right
The Bottom Line
We love the fact that we can sleep in just about any position on this Winkbeds pillow-top mattress. Whether it’s the side or back, we can fall asleep in our own comfort zone and wake up refreshed, supported, and without any body aches. Winkbeds is the mattress to recommend for partners that have different sleeping position, or anyone who wants to have some contouring with just the right amount of sinking.
Save $200 on Winkbeds with code NINJA200
Brentwood Home Oceano – Best Luxury Pillow Top
In a category designed for luxury, Brentwood Home’s Oceano stands out. This premium mattress combines a five-zone support core and responsive micro-support coils with CertiPURE-US® certified cooling gel memory foam.
And for the pillow top layer, the Oceano uses a combination of natural poly-silk fiber, GOTS certified organic wool, 2-inches of serene cool air luxe foam™ and a plant-based Tencel™ blended fabric cover. In total, Oceano has nine layers of premium materials in this medium-plush luxurious mattress.
Features:
- Free shipping and returns
- Unparalleled pillow-top design for optimal comfort
- 3,163 individually-wrapped coils for exceptional support
- Sleeps cool
- Uses non-toxic and organic materials (Greenguard Gold certified)
- Hand made in the USA
- 25-year warranty
- 365-night sleep trial
The Bottom Line
We’ve reviewed virtually all of Brentwood Home’s mattress because they are intelligently designed using high-quality materials. The Oceano Luxury Hybrid is their most popular mattress—and for good reason! This is perhaps our favorite pillow-top option.
Save $175 on Oceano with code NINJA
Helix LUXE – Best Customizable Pillow Top Mattress
What sets Helix apart from its competitors is the level of customization they offer. When shopping with Helix, you start by taking their Sleep Quiz and then you’ll receive their recommended options.
There are six basic designs for the Helix LUXE. The best pillow top mattress for you will depend on two main factors:
- Your dominant sleeping position (side vs back vs stomach)
- Your desired level of firmness (soft, medium, and firm)
Helix’s innovative approach allows you to customize your selection based on your personal needs. And if you’re not certain which option (even after taking the sleep quiz), go with the Helix Midnight LUXE. It’s a medium feel pillow-top mattress designed for side sleepers.
Helix mattresses have layers of memory foam, high-grade polyfoam, gel Visco, DureDense foam, and wrapped coils. A breathable Tencel cover and a premium pillow-top adds an additional layer of comfort. Helix is also one of our picks for the top 10 most comfortable mattresses.
Features
- Free shipping and returns
- Can be customized according to customer preferences
- Zoned lumbar support coils
- Ultra-breathable Tencel cover
- Manufactured in the U.S.
- 100-night trial without risk
- 15-year Warranty
- Cooling factor while sleeping
Bottomline
The customization feature that Helix offers is something that should be more common! It’s a delightful offer that many would jump to take. The Helix LUXE is easily one of the top contenders for the best pillow top mattress.
Save $200 on Helix LUXE with code NINJA200
Awara – Best Value Pillow Top Mattress
The Awara mattress has everything you look for in a hybrid, Euro-top style mattress: a 9-inch layer of innerspring coils, 4 inches of natural Dunlop latex, and a quilted cover made of organic fibers.
Awara manages to use organic materials and still keep their Queen-size mattress under $1,000. To our knowledge, they are the only company to manage this.
The Awara Organic Hybrid sleeps “luxury firm,” which means it should provide you with a comfortable sleep whether you’re a back, side, or stomach sleeper. A plush Euro Top cover is included on the mattress, made from highly breathable and soft New Zealand wool and organic cotton.
With a 365-night trial, free shipping and returns, and a “forever” warranty, Awara makes it easy to give their premium mattress a try.
Features:
- Free shipping and returns
- New Zealand wool and organic quilted cotton Euro Top
- Natural Rainforest Alliance Certified Dunlop latex
- Chemical-free (no toxic off-gassing)
- Comfortable for any sleeping style
- Sleeps cool
- Forever warranty
- 365 sleep trial
The Bottom Line
Given the quality of materials, the excellent overall sleep experience, and the industry-beating pricing, Awara is an excellent pick for the best pillow-top mattress.
Save $300 on Awara with code NINJA
Avocado Green Mattress – Best Organic Pillow Top
The Avocado Green mattress is a natural pillow-top mattress that’s made with natural latex rubber, organic cotton (certified), natural wool, and a whopping 1,414 pocketed coils for premium support. It contains no polyurethane that could trigger off your allergies, or any toxic chemicals as fire retardants.
The wool is enough of a fire retardant on its own, and has no nasty synthetic stuff to play havoc with your health. This makes it one of the best pillow top mattresses one should look out for. Avocado Green is also one of our top picks for the best non-toxic mattress.
But more than just being all-natural, Avocado’s mattress has excellent motion transfer, responsiveness, and comfort. When you opt for their Euro pillow-top option, you get an extra 2-inch layer of organic latex for additional comfort and pressure relief.
With the pillow-top, Avocado is rated a 6 out of 10 on the firmness/comfort scale. Although everyone is different, for most sleepers, this is an ideal rating.
Features
- Free shipping and returns
- GOTS certified organic cotton, wool, and natural latex
- Greenguard Gold-Certified with organic materials
- Excellent non-toxic, hybrid construction
- Solid zoned back support
- Made Safe certified
- 365-night trial
- 25-year warranty
- Handmade in the U.S.
The Bottom Line
We love the zoned support system, with pressure points especially suited to every kind of body. This will ensure that back problems become a thing of the past and the mattress lasts a long time. If you love the environment as well as your beauty sleep, Avocado is the best mattress choice for you! The natural and organic materials come from sustainable sources, making sure of the tiniest carbon footprint possible. See Sleeping Ninjas’ in-depth Avocado Green Mattress Review.
Dreamfoam Ultimate Dreams EuroTop Mattress
The Dreamfoam EuroTop mattress combines the amazing comfort of a plush top layer with the firm support we need for our spines and backs. You can now enjoy extreme softness in a mattress without worrying about what your back will feel like in the morning. The price is also absolutely reasonable for the value and performance you get – thus, making it one of the best pillow top mattresses.
This Dreamfoarm EuroTop mattress is around 12 inches thick and has several firmness levels that can be adjusted according to preference. It’s made in the U.S. and the materials come from the same place. There’s a Tri-Zone foam in the very middle for giving support, while the pillow-top allows for contouring and luxurious comfort.
Features
- Tri Zone core minimizes motion transfer
- Core also provides excellent support for back and side sleepers
- Certipur-US quality
- Good for any sleeping position
- Extreme comfort, relaxation, and soothing effect
Cons
- Takes 72 hours to reach its full shape once opened
- Might lose springiness in the middle with daily use
The Bottom Line
We love the fact that this Dreamfoam Ultimate Dreams pillow-top mattress offers pure luxury. For most customers, it feels like lying on a cloud and drifting off to heavenly sleep. If you’re in the market for a budget mattress but have some back or body pain issues, look no further!
The Zinus Ultra Comfort Spring Mattress
The Zinus Ultra Comfort is a memory foam mattress that will give you all the contouring and confirming you need. No matter what your body type is, this mattress will be sure to give you the support and comfort you need. Besides checking its ranking in the pillow top mattress reviews, you can lie down and experience the pressure-releasing support!
This mattress is infused with a natural extract from green tea instead of those awful chemicals that ruin your mattress experience.
Technical Specs
The Zinus Ultra is CertiPUR-US Certified and is hence durable, comfy, and promises high performance. Most of these items have at least 3 inches of memory foam layer at the very top. This is followed by 2 inches of comfort foam, and 3.5 inches of high-density foam with airflow included. Another 3.5 inches of base support high-density foam follows.
Pros
- Infused with natural green tea extracts for anti-oxidant and freshness purposes
- Shipped in compressed packaging
- Suitable for all sleeping positions
- iCoil® technology for limited motion transfer
Cons
- Might take a few days to decompress, especially in cold climates
- Some complaints have been received about the smell
The Bottom Line
We absolutely adore the natural infusion of green tea extracts for coolness and freshness. If you want a comfy and undisturbed sleep on a naturally fresh bed, grab the Zinus Ultra Comfort and never look back!
Signature Sleep Coil-Encased Soft Pillow Top Mattress
The Signature Sleep Coil-Encased is one of those mattresses that seem to boast just about any feature known to man! It will keep you dry during the night no matter what kind of climate you’re in.
Pillow top mattress reviews are the proof: the pillow-top assures deep and soft comfort. The dryness and moisture absorbing also mean that it’s not going to grow mold. The coils inside ensure that you get the support along with the contouring that you need for the perfect sleep every single night.
Technical Specs
Each of the coils in this 13-inch thick mattress is encased separately from the others. Each coil is around ten-inch long. The pillow-top makes for an incredibly comfortable experience and the coils underneath give maximum support. The materials are moisture-wicking, breathable, and extremely durable to boot.
Pros
- Long coils make for proper weight distribution and contouring features
- Coils also relieve pressure and minimize restlessness
- Free of harmful fire retardants, ozone depleters, formaldehyde, mercury, and lead
- Available in several sizes to fit any kind of bed
- Three-inch zone foam for proper pressure relief and minimal motion transfer
Cons
- Might develop soft spots with extended use
- Some issues with sizes, especially for the average American consumer
The Bottom Line
We love the coils in this Signature Sleep mattress more than anything else. They give a contouring effect that matches the memory foam pillow-top, but still provide the right kind of support for back and side sleepers. Do you have a partner who’s constantly moving around when asleep? Say no more—get this mattress and sleep soundly through all their shenanigans without getting awake!
What Is A Pillow Top Mattress And Why Should You Care?
A pillowtop mattress has an extra cushiony layer at the very top. This makes it firm, supportive, but with a level of softness that can’t be beaten. It can hence support your back and still leave you without the aches and pains of extremely firm mattresses.
Pillow top mattress reviews should tell you that these items give you a feeling of luxurious sinking without the harm of an unsupported back or side. You should also find that the cushioning layer prevents any uncomfortable situation arousing from uneven patches, such as from the springs wearing out.
Luxury rules! That’s what makes the pillow top mattresses the best pillow top mattresses you can find.
Pillow Top vs. Mattress Topper
While reading the pillow top mattress reviews, you may ask why anyone would spring for a special pillow-top mattress when they can simply buy a plush mattress topper. After all, the topper can be easily changed and is much cheaper than getting a whole new mattress.
The fact is that mattress toppers are quite different from mattresses. A mattress that’s lacking in something needs a topper in order to make it bearable. A good pillow-top mattress, on the other hand, just might be the complete package you need for your sore neck, back, and shoulder. This is one of the reasons why it’s considered one of the best pillow top mattresses.
Pillow-top is not a measurement on the comfort scale, but the name of a certain kind of mattress construction. The pillow top mattress reviews would say that one should choose a mattress according to the layers and materials used.
If you can get a high-quality pillow-top mattress, it’s probably going to last as long as a lesser quality mattress and a soft mattress topper combined. In fact, the investment in the pillow-top may work out better than the cheaper option.
Plus, you don’t get to test out how the topper would pair with your bed while purchasing it. When getting a pillow-top, however, you get to have a trial for several nights. Whatever you choose to buy, make sure the materials are of good quality and suits your sleeping position. Therefore, you should read the pillow top mattress reviews before making a purchase.
Materials Are Used in a Pillow Top Mattress
The materials mostly used for the cushioning in a pillow-top are combinations of feathers, wool, cotton, latex, and memory foam. The more natural and organic the materials are, the better experience you’ll have. This is why natural latex is one of the top choices for a luxurious pillow-top. There’s usually a spring system in the middle.
See our review of the best latex hybrids.
The comfort and luxuriousness of a pillow-top are also based on the depth of quilting involved. The deeper the cushioned layer on top, the softer your experience will be. Whether this is a good thing for you or not depends on your sleeping needs and preferences as a couple or as an individual.
As you make the purchase decision by looking at the pillow top mattress reviews, don’t forget to match your sleeping needs with the chosen mattress.
Points to Consider When Purchasing a Pillow Top Mattress
Before buying one of the best pillow top mattresses, there are a few factors to consider. Every item has its pros and cons, and they may vary according to customers’ requirements. Hence, be sure to take into account the following:
- You won’t be able to flip it over when it starts sagging. A simple one-sided mattress is all you get since the pillowed layer is only at the top.
- When the top layer wears out, you should either live with a non-pillow-top or start thinking about getting a new mattress or mattress topper
- You may find these mattresses on the pricey side. However, there are some cheaper alternatives like buying a pillowed top.
- Make sure the mattress fits your bed so check the pillow top mattress reviews before buying.
- If you have a back problem, make sure to get a thick and firm mattress.
- Make sure you know how to clean a pillow-top mattress regularly. This will keep it in good condition and make it last longer.
- The warranty offered by the best pillow top mattresses should be at least 8-10 years
- Check the materials used in the making of the pillow-top. If memory foam is too hot for you, or if you’re allergic to feathers/wool, don’t go for these options.
Still wondering about which pillow-top mattress to buy?
Best Pillow Top Mattress Review Conclusion
Pillow top mattresses are by far the best kind that one can get for comfort and support in one foam. You’ll get the benefits of a luxurious sleep, no doubt. Plus, if you conduct your research and make wise decisions, you may very well get rid of your body aches and pains.
It’s highly recommended that you consider the pillow-top mattress reviews before making a purchase. After all, a mattress is something that you’ll buy once in a decade. They should hence live up to their cost and provide a soothing sleep every night.
Once you choose the pillow-top mattress according to your sleeping preference, you’ll more likely say good-bye to your backache or neck pain caused by sleeping on the wrong mattress.
Andrea is a professional freelance writer based out of Kentucky who has researched and reviewed over 40 major mattress brands. She digs politics, activism, and sarcasm. Andrea spent over 5 years in the medical field before deciding to follow her dreams for a lot less pay but a lot more happiness. She’s a mom to two great kids.