Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding: A Definitive Comparison Guide to the Best Mattress

Summary: This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding to help you select the best mattress. DisclosureSleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

__________

Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding Highlights

The Casper mattress offers:

  • Temperature regulating technology in every layer of the mattress
  • A four-layer hybrid construction featuring high-quality memory foam and latex materials
  • A standard limited warranty and sleep trial period to keep your purchase protected
  • A perfect ratio of softness to firmness back by real-life customer reviews
  • A timely, friendly, and courteous customer service department

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress offers:

  • A family-friendly price tag
  • A 3-layer hybrid construction featuring high-quality materials
  • A wide selection of series and firmness options available
  • Patented TitanFlex foam, exclusive to the Brooklyn Bedding brand, that guarantees comfort and support
  • Infusions of proprietary cooling technology

Let’s dive right into our comparison of two popular mattress brands, Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding, to see which option comes out on top.

Construction: What’s It Made Out Of?

To begin our Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding comparison review, we’ll take a look at the construction and details of the specific layers and materials used in both mattresses.

casper vs brooklyn bedding mattress comparison

Casper Construction

The Casper company has created a 4-layer hybrid mattress that combines the very best qualities of memory foam and latex to provide their customers with unsurpassed comfort and support.

Breathable Memory Foam

Each Casper mattress is first topped with a layer of their breathable memory foam. Casper specially formulates their memory foam with an open-cell construction. This unique formulation allows their material to provide all of the benefits of memory foam, such as pressure relief and joint cradling, without the most common drawbacks. Their foam is designed to always remain comfortable with an added layer of ultra-breathability to keep you cool and dry.

Pressure Relieving Memory Foam

Up next is Casper’s layer of high-quality pressure relieving memory foam. This specific layer is where you can expect to reap all of those fantastic memory foam benefits. Casper has specifically designed this layer to provide unsurpassed joint cradling and pressure point relief for a peaceful and pain-free night’s sleep.

Zoned Support Memory Foam

Casper’s zoned support layer is the mattress’s last layer of memory foam material. It features perfectly spaced areas of soft and firmer memory foam material to allow sleepers to achieve the very best benefits in all the right areas. The memory foam under pressure points such as shoulders and hips are softer while the areas under the neck and lumbar region offer more support.

This helps to ensure proper alignment, adequate support, and optimal comfort.

Supportive Latex Foam

Casper brings up the bottom of their mattress with a layer of supportive latex foam. This layer guarantees that Casper users will always get the necessary support, stability, and firmness from their mattress. It also reinforces the entire mattress and enhances the overall performance of the above memory foam layers.

brooklyn bedding vs casper

Brooklyn Bedding Construction

The Brooklyn Bedding company feels that their hybrid, 3-layer construction of high-quality materials will provide their customers with the very best in both comfort and support.

TitanFlex Comfort

The top of each Brooklyn Bedding mattress features 2 inches of patented, exclusive TitanFlex foam. The Brooklyn Bedding company has specially engineered this proprietary foam with unique technology that reacts and adjusts instantly to your movements. This layer is also infused with Brooklyn Bedding’s patented Titanium gel that’s designed to help keep you cool and dry as well as promotes a healthier, anti-bacterial surface.

TitanFlex Support

The core of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is constructed with 2 inches of TitanFlex support foam. This is the same material as the above layer, just with a higher density. This allows for a transition layer and provides a firmer feel. This layer is designed to perfectly contour around every individual body shape and size and provides unsurpassed deep compression support.

Ascension Pocketed Coils

The foundation of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is constructed with a 6” layer of ascension pocketed coils. Based on the size of the mattress, each Brooklyn Bedding mattress can feature up to 1,024 coils. Each coil has been perfectly engineered and pocketed individually to provide perfect responsiveness and reinforce the entire structure of the mattress.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the overall construction of the Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper mattresses, we’re giving the win to Brooklyn Bedding. Casper has one more layer than their counterpart, but Brooklyn Bedding features more proprietary materials and allows for a deep, overall relaxation.

Temperature Control

Up next, we’ll be taking a look at the temperature control offered by the Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding mattresses to see which option will keep you the coolest and dryest through the night.

casper vs brooklyn bedding comparison

Casper Temperature Control

Casper has ensured that every last inch of their product is equipped with properties and technology that’s designed to keep you cool and dry night after night. The open-cell foam formulation featured in the top layer of the Casper mattress actually harnesses the powers of convection and conduction to draw in heat and move it away from the body. The memory foam directly beneath the top layer provides adequate airflow and breathability in addition to drawing the heat down from the top layer.

Unlike many other options, Casper even utilizes their base layer to help keep you cool. The layer of latex foam bringing up the bottom of the Casper mattress absorbs the heat that’s been drawn down from the above layers and distributes it through the bottom of the mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding Temperature Control

The Brooklyn Bedding company has equipped both layers of their TitanFlex foam with Titanium cooling gel infusions. The addition of this proprietary ingredient allows the mattress to actually regulate your body temperature throughout the night. This helps to always keep your body at a neutral temperature, reduces or eliminates night sweats, and avoids hot spots in your mattress.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the temperature control offered by the Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper mattresses, Casper takes the win. They utilize every last inch of their product to keep you cool and you’ll notice below in our review section that Brooklyn Bedding customers aren’t as impressed with the cooling properties of the product.

Overall Comfort: Firmness vs Softness

In this category, we’ll be comparing the overall comfort as well as the softness to firmness ratio of the Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding mattresses.

casper vs brooklyn bedding comparison

Casper Comfort

The Casper mattress has a pretty common firmness level at medium-firm, making it a great option for the majority of consumers or those that aren’t familiar with their personal firmness preferences. As you’ll notice in our “Construction” category above, the Casper mattress is primarily constructed of memory foam.

Memory foam is certainly known for its unsurpassed ability to cradle joints and relieve pressure. However, it’s not usually praised for its firmness or support. Casper combats this common memory foam issue with the addition of their supportive latex base layer. This ensures that Casper customers will experience all the comfort and plushness of memory foam without sacrificing any of that crucial support, stability, or firmness.

brooklyn bedding vs casper mattress comparison review

Brooklyn Bedding Comfort

Brooklyn Bedding has harnessed the very best properties of memory foam and latex and combined those benefits into their proprietary TitanFlex foam, ensuring that their users are getting the most comfortable and supportive sleeping experience possible. These layers are designed to provide all the responsiveness of latex with the cradling abilities of memory foam.

The top layer of softer TitanFlex foam reacts instantly to your body movements throughout the night. The denser, firmer TitianFlex foam beneath serves as the Brooklyn Bedding’s transition layer and provides crucial deep compression support. The base layer bringing up the bottom of the mattress guarantees support and stability.

Brooklyn Bedding has set themselves apart in another way, as well. Unlike many companies that only offer one or two different mattress options, Brooklyn Bedding carries a wide selection of different series as well as 3 different firmness level for each option they carry. This helps customers to somewhat customize their purchase to specifically fit their needs. However, the different series and firmness options do vary in price.

Who Wins?

In the comfort category of Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper, Brooklyn Bedding has the leg up. Both mattresses are equipped with tons of different comfort and support benefit. But, Brooklyn Bedding utilizes special materials and offers a variety of options.

Price: Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper

Below, we’ll compare the prices of the Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding mattresses to see which option offers the most bang for your buck.

Casper Price

The Caper mattress company offer their product at a pretty fair price considering all the benefits they have to offer. Their queen-size option is just under $1000 and their larger sizes don’t break the $1500 mark.

The prices of the Casper mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $595
  • Twin XL – $645
  • Full – $895
  • Queen – $995
  • King – $1195
  • California King – $1195

There are, of course, cheaper options on the market. But, there are certainly more expensive, as well. The Casper mattress offers deeply ingrained temperature control, high-quality construction, and optimal comfort. Plus, you can upgrade from a king to a California king-size for the same price.

Brooklyn Bedding Price

The Brooklyn Bedding company offers several different options, all of which vary in price quite a bit. But, their most popular option, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Series, comes with a pretty average price tag. Their queen-size option is just a hair under $1000 and their larger sizes still don’t break over $1500.

The prices of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Series mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $599
  • Twin XL – $649
  • Full – $799
  • Queen – $949
  • King – $1149
  • California King – $1149

Again, the prices of a Brooklyn Bedding mattress can truly vary quite a bit depending upon the series and firmness level that you choose. But you can always expect a high-quality product that promises to keep you comfortable and supported. And you can upgrade from a king to a California king-size at no additional cost.

Who Wins?

In the price category of Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper, the Casper mattress just barely has the upper hand. Their sizes are cheaper across the board by only just a few dollars. But, if you’re purchasing different series or firmness options from Brooklyn Bedding, the price does go up significantly, giving Casper a bigger win.

Pros & Cons Of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding

Here, we’ll take a look at the reviews of Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding to see what customers love about the mattresses as well as some of their most common issues.

casper vs brooklyn bedding

What Do Users Love About Casper?

Casper users are enamored with the perfect ratio of softness to firmness that they get out of their mattress. According to real-life reviewers, Casper has made good on their guarantee to provide optimal comfort and gentle support in all the right places.

Several Casper reviewers have even noted that they suffer from pain-inducing ailments such as Fibro or arthritis and their Casper mattress has greatly reduced or even eliminated their nighttime tossing and turning as well as their morning stiffness and pain.

Pros

  • The Casper mattress offers a lot of great amenities and benefits for a fairly budget-friendly price
  • Customers back the claim that the Casper mattress has the perfect balance of softness to firmness
  • Casper protects your purchase with an industry-standard sleep trial and warranty period
  • Every layer of the Casper mattress is equipped with cooling properties
  • Reviewers brag that Casper’s customer service department is polite, timely, and courteous

What Are The Common Drawbacks Of Casper?

Almost every review we read was filled with lots of praise about the performance of the mattress. The biggest complaint we found was actually over the smell. Due to the way the Casper mattress is packed for shipping, some “fresh foam” odors can be trapped in the plastic and released upon breaking the vacuum-packed seal.

Generally, this off-gassing odor will dissipate with adequate ventilation within 48-72 hours. But, many Casper users have noticed that the smell is strong and tends to linger long past the 3-day mark. Some users have even noted that the smell was still noticeable after 2 weeks.

Cons

  • Because of the way the Casper mattress is compressed and shipped, it can take up to 72-hours for the mattress to completely decompress and be ready for use
  • Users that sleep with a partner that’s larger than them have noticed that the mattress tends to lean to one side
  • Some Casper customers have complained that their mattress broke down quickly – some in as little as 6 months
  • The Casper mattress leaves its users susceptible to rolling off the bed or causing premature wear due to a lack of sufficient edge support

What Do Users Love About Brooklyn Bedding?

It’s easy to see that Brooklyn Bedding users absolutely love their mattress. But the biggest praise lies in the cloud-like pressure relieving properties. The hybrid construction with unique, proprietary materials allows the mattress to gently mold around joints and pressure points, leaving users perfectly cradled and gently supported. Many reviewers claimed that lying on their Brooklyn Bedding mattress gave them a floating-like sensation.

Pros

  • Your Brooklyn Bedding mattress ships and arrives at your door quickly
  • There are several different Brooklyn Bedding mattress options available and their website features a sleep profile tool that helps you determine which is best for you
  • Unlike many foam options, the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is equipped with adequate edge support
  • The Brooklyn Bedding company proudly offers military and first responder discounts
  • Customer reviews note that the mattress sets up quickly and easily

What Are The Common Drawbacks Of Brooklyn Bedding?

The biggest complaint surrounding the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is the lack of durability. Almost all Brooklyn Bedding users are highly satisfied with the mattress for the first several months to a couple of years of use. But, a large percentage have complained that it didn’t last. Many have noted that within the first few months to year their mattress started to break down or sag so badly that it was beyond use.

Cons

  • Some reviewers have complained that it’s difficult to find sheets that will fit the Brooklyn Bedding mattress properly
  • Couples that share their mattress have noticed that they begin to roll into the middle of the bed after extended use
  • A few reviewers have noted that they’re not satisfied with the firmness level of the mattress
  • A large handful of Brooklyn Bedding customers have noted that the cooling properties don’t perform well under warm conditions or during the warm seasons

Warranty: Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper

In this category, we’ll be comparing the fine details of the warranties offered by the Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding companies.

casper vs lull mattress review

Casper Warranty

The Casper creators were very disappointed with how quickly customers were expected to settle on a mattress. They wanted to ensure that each Casper customer had plenty of time to try the mattress and determine if it really was as great as they’d hoped. That’s why the Casper company allows purchasers to use their mattress in their own home for a full 100 nights. If you’re not completely satisfied, Casper will issue a full refund and arrange to pick the mattress up from your home.

If it turns out that you do love your Casper purchase then you’ll remain protected by a 10-year limited warranty. The terms of the warranty are pretty standard for the industry. Casper will repair or replace your mattress at no cost to you if it’s found to have an indention of greater than 1″, any malfunctions in the zipper mechanism, or any faults or defects in the mattress materials. Casper does not cover any damages incurred from improper use or abuse or any Casper mattress purchased “as is” or from an unauthorized dealer.

brooklyn bedding vs casper

Brooklyn Bedding Warranty

Brooklyn Bedding proudly stands behind their product with a 120-night sleep trial period and a 10-year limited warranty. As soon as you receive your Brooklyn Bedding mattress, you have 120 nights to try the product in your own home and determine if it’s the best option for you. If it turns out that you don’t love the mattress, the company will issue a refund less any shipping or processing fees. Brooklyn Bedding does ask that you try the mattress for at least 30 days to allow sufficient time for your body to adjust and it does look like you’ll be responsible for returning the product.

If you decide to keep your mattress, you’ll remain protected by an industry-standard 10-year limited warranty. Brooklyn Bedding will repair or replace your mattress within a reasonable time frame if it’s found to have any defects in cell structure, splitting or cracking in the foam material, or any sags or indentations that are greater than one inch.

Brooklyn Bedding does not take responsibility for damages resulting from improper use, an improper frame, any normal increase in softness, any stains, or normal wear and tear on the product. They also only cover the original purchaser of the mattress and do not cover products bought “as is” or from an unauthorized dealer.

Who Wins?

Both companies offer a pretty standard sleep trial and warranty period. But when it comes to the warranty section of Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper, we’re giving the win to Casper. Brooklyn Bedding does offer 20 additional days in the sleep trial period, but they do not pick the mattress up from your home and they do not refund any shipping or processing costs.

About The Companies

In the last section of our Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding comparison, we’ll go over a few of the important details surrounding the mattress companies.

casper vs brooklyn bedding

Casper Company

The Casper mattress company was founded out of frustration at the way people were expected to buy a new mattress. The founders felt that bright showrooms with pushy salesmen and inflated prices were ineffective and unnecessary. Not to mention, the mattresses were usually low-quality.

So, in 2014, 5 individuals came together to create a solution to the common mattress buying woes. They founded an online, direct-to-consumer company and invented a high-quality mattress that was budget-friendly and allowed customers to try the product in their own homes. Since their founding, the Casper company has been recognized by Good Morning America, The New York Times, and Forbes. They also received Good Housekeeping’s 2018 Lab Pick as well as the title of one of the Most Innovative Companies by Fast Company in 2017.

Brooklyn Bedding Company

John and Rob Irwin founded the Brooklyn Bedding company after a start as liquidators. In 1995 they started to dip their toes in the mattress industry and even deconstructed a few mattresses to determine how they could make the very best mattress around. They eventually found themselves an old bread truck and a Motorola brick phone and decided to give the mattress industry a shot.

The brothers quickly began selling their product on Amazon and were some of the first to utilize the “bed in a box” concept in 2008. All these years later Brooklyn Bedding remains one of the few companies that build and sell direct and still manufactures their own product. In 2018 the company opened their first permanent showroom at the Las Vegas market.

What’s The Final Conclusion Of Our Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding Comparison Review?

This particular mattress review was a close race. Both mattresses offer high-quality craftsmanship, high-grade construction, and optimal comfort and support. And, on the other end on the spectrum, both mattresses have received complaints about a lack of overall durability.

But in the end, when it comes to Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper, we’re giving the win to Casper. Their warranty and sleep trial period is a bit more appealing, they’re price is just slightly cheaper when compared to Brooklyn Bedding’s most common series – but shows a big difference between their luxury options, and their cooling properties seem to perform better than their Brooklyn Bedding counterpart – ultimately making the Casper mattress a scary good deal.

__________

See also: Brooklyn Bedding vs Leesa, Casper vs Leesa, and Casper vs Nectar.