Casper vs Tuft and Needle: Comparison Buyer’s Guide to the Best Mattress

Summary: This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Casper vs Tuft and Needle to help you select the best mattress. DisclosureSleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

__________

Deciding which mattress is best for you or your family can be frustrating. There are so many options available these days from tons of different companies and made from dozens of different materials. It can be difficult to sift through all the different possibilities and find the best mattress to fit your individual needs.

Now, we can’t choose a mattress for you, but we can help take off a bit of the pressure when it comes to making your decision. We’ve put together a complete comparison of Casper vs Tuft and Needle, two popular mattresses available on the market today. We’ve even compared the two with convenient categories such as overall comfort and price to help you make the best, well-informed decision for your mattress purchase.  

Construction: What Are Casper vs Tuft and Needle Made From?

One of the important things you’ll come across when searching for a new mattress is the materials that it’s made of. There are so many different options available on the market today and they all offer individual qualities. No one material is necessarily better than the other. However, certain materials will provide certain things. For example, memory foam is known for its cradling and molding abilities, while latex is known for its durability.

It’s important to determine what material will best suit your individual needs. So, when it comes down to Casper vs Tuft and Needle, what exactly are these mattresses made of?

casper vs tuft and needle review

Casper Construction

The Casper mattress is constructed with four individual layers of memory foam on top of a thick layer of premium latex foam. The top found memory foam layers are specially designed to mold around the unique shape of your body, offering a cradling comforting feeling that relieves pressure from joints and pressure points such as the hips and shoulders. The topmost layer features specifically zoned support sections to help ensure that you’re getting the right balance of firmness vs softness in all the necessary places. This zoned support construction also helps to guarantee that you’re achieving proper neck and spine alignment for the most comfortable and healthy sleep.

Underneath the layers of pressure-relieving memory foam is a thick layer of high-quality premium latex foam. This bottom layer reinforces the whole mattress and provides the mattress with a supportive core and base. This helps to guarantee that you’re getting the firm support that you need and provides overall stability to the entire mattress. Casper also promises that they never use filler foams, only high-quality products.

tuft and needle vs casper mattress review

Tuft and Needle Construction

The creators of the Tuft and Needle decided to only put in their mattress what was necessary. They felt that tons of additional layers only bumped up the cost without really adding any additional amenities. If the material doesn’t offer a better feel or additional airflow, then they didn’t include it in their mattress. Therefore, the Tuft and Needle mattresses are constructed of only two high-quality layers.

The top layer of the Tuft and Needle mattress features a layer of Tuft and Needle adaptive foam. This specially formulated foam is designed to provide soft, comfortable pressure point relief. This helps to alleviate stiffness and joint pain upon waking. This layer is also infused with graphite and cooling gel to help wick away heat and keep you cool and comfortable. The entire mattress features a soft, breathable cover.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the construction of the Casper vs Tuft and Needle, Casper has the leg up in this category. Not only does their 4 layers of memory foam combined with the bottom latex layer provide optimal comfort and support, their top layer is specifically zoned with varying levels of firmness to provide the best sleeping surface.

Temperature Regulation: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

No one wants to be stuck waking up sweaty and sticky or tossing and turning all throughout the night due to a mattress that won’t keep you cool. You want to ensure that whatever mattress you settle on is equipped with efficient temperature regulation qualities so you’ll guaranteed wake up refreshed and ready to take on the day every day.

When we take a look at Tuft and Needle vs Casper, who provides the best temperature regulation?

Casper Temperature Control 

The Casper mattress is a real leader when it comes to temperature control. The creators of the Casper have utilized every last layer of their mattress to ensure that it will remain cool and comfortable throughout the night, night after night. The very topmost layer of this mattress features an open cell design that uses the power of convection and conduction to literally pull the natural heat away from your body as you sleep.

The memory foam layers of the Casper are designed to provide optimal airflow and breathability. This extracts heat from the very top of the mattress to ensure that no heat is left trapped against your skin.

The very bottom layer of latex foam also serves as another line of defense against heat retention. The premium latex foam absorbs the heat that is pulled down from the top layers of the mattress and disturbs it evenly through the bottom of the mattress, away from your body. The combination of heat retention defense in every single layer of the Casper mattress means that not only will it be combating natural body heat, but it will actually leave a cooler sleeping surface.

Tuft and Needle Temperature Control

The Tuft and Needle mattress features two lines of defense against heat retention. First and foremost, their Tuft and Needle adaptive foam layer is infused with graphite and cooling gel. These additions to the foam are designed to wick away body heat quickly to leave you feeling cool and comfortable.

On top of the layer of cool foam is a breathable cover surrounding the entire mattress. This covered is made to promote airflow and provide optimal breathability so that no heat is trapped against the skin throughout the night.

Who Wins?

In Tuft and Needle vs Casper temperature control, Casper takes the win. While the Tuft and Needle has included some heat control measures, the Casper utilizes every last layer of their mattress to ensure that the entire mattress is working to not only draw away natural heat but actually leave a cooler more comfortable sleeping surface.

casper vs tuft and needle mattress review

Overall Comfort: Softness vs Firmness

When looking for the best mattress for you, above all else, you want to ensure that you’re going to be comfortable. There are options available on the market today that can provide extreme firmness or even a super-soft plush mattress. However, the majority of sleepers are looking for something that’s somewhere right in the middle, a mattress that will provide firm support while still remaining soft and comfortable.

So, how does Tuft and Needle vs Casper stack up in the overall comfort category?

Casper Firmness

The Casper mattress is described as a medium-firm option. The top layers of the mattress are primarily constructed of memory foam, which isn’t really known for its firmness, rather it’s soft, molding and cradling capabilities that relieve pressure and joint pain. However, underneath the layers of plush memory foam is a thick layer of supportive latex foam that provides a level of firmness and support through the memory foam.

If you’re searching for something that is super-firm or super-soft, then the Casper is most likely not the best option for you. But, if you’re like most sleepers looking for a good ratio of plush comfort to supportive firmness, then the Casper provides just that.

tuft and needle vs casper mattress review

Tuft and Needle Firmness

The Tuft and Needle is another medium-firm option. They use high-quality adaptive foam to ensure that the surface of the mattress is soft and plush to provide optimal comfort, and a supportive base layer to provide you with a firm, supportive foundation.

The Tuft and Needle, much like the Casper mattress, most likely won’t satisfy the needs of someone that is looking for an extremely firm or extremely soft mattress. However, if you’re looking for something supportive that may even be a bit on the soft side, then the Tuft and Needle is a great option.

Who Wins?

While both mattresses are equipped to offer comfortable yet firm support, we believe that when it comes to Tuft and Needle vs Casper, Casper takes the win here. The Tuft and Needle mattress is noted to be a bit on the soft side, while the Casper provides the perfect ratio of supportive firmness to plush softness and their zoned construction ensures that you’re getting the softness and firmness in the correct places.

best mattress under 500 tuft and needle

Price: Casper vs Tuft and Needle

Buying a new mattress is a big purchase that requires a good amount of research and consideration before you settle on a final decision. One of the most important things to consider is the price. You want to ensure that you’re getting a high-quality product that will keep you cool and comfortable for years to come, but you don’t want it to break the bank if it doesn’t have to.

When we consider the price of Casper vs Tuft and Needle, who takes home the win for the best price?

Casper

The Casper mattress is available for $805.50 for a full-size mattress, $895.50 for a queen-size, and $1075.50 for the king-size option. For the qualities and amenities that the Casper has to offer, those are fairly neutral prices. Of course, there are more expansive as well as cheaper options available on the market. However, the old saying “you get what you pay for” definitely holds true here.

Tuft and Needle

The Tuft and Needle mattress comes with a price tag of $475 for a full-size, $575 for a queen, and $700 for both the king and California king size option. For the quality and performance that you’ll be getting out of a Tuft and Needle mattress, these are truly great prices.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the price of Casper vs Tuft and Needle, Tuft and Needle certainly take home the gold. Their mattresses are available at a savings of nearly $400, and you can upgrade from a king to a California king size for no additional cost.

Pros & Cons of Casper vs Tuft and Needle

One of the very best ways to ensure that you’re making an informed decision on your mattress purchase is to look at the reviews from consumers who have already purchased it. This way you’re getting personal opinions and experiences without ever having to spend a dime. Are there certain things that previous buyers didn’t like about the specific mattress? Was there anything that buyers just absolutely loved?

Let’s take a look at the good and not so great reviews of Casper vs Tuft and Needle.

casper vs tuft and needle review

What Do Reviewers Love About Casper?

Above all else, reviewers have raved on about the overall comfort and perfect ratio of softness vs firmness in the Casper mattress. Many reviews have noted that they suffer from ailments such as arthritis or chronic back and neck pain. According to their testimonies, the Casper mattress has either greatly reduced or completely alleviated their pain and discomfort upon waking. Many reviewers report little or no stiffness or pressure and are able to wake up feeling rejuvenated and ready to take on the day.

Overall Pros

  • The sleep trial and warranty that Casper offers are ideal
  • The Casper mattress has a pretty affordable price tag in comparison to many other options on the market
  • The just right overall comfort and firmness vs softness can help alleviate joint problems and pain
  • Casper utilizes every single layer of their mattress to ensure absolutely optimal temperature regulation and a cool sleeping surface
  • According to reviewers, Casper’s customer service is timely and friendly

What Are The Drawbacks Of Casper?

It’s common for all mattresses that have been rolled and compressed for shipping to have a bit of off-gassing upon opening. Usually, this odor will dissipate within 72 hours with adequate ventilation. However, several reviewers have reported that the Casper mattress has a lingering odor that often lasts up to weeks or even sometimes months. Some consumers have even reported that this smell makes it difficult or even impossible to use their mattress.

Overall Cons

  • Due to the way the Casper is packaged and shipped, it can take up to a full 72-hours for the mattress to expand fully and be ready for use
  • The Casper does not feature any edge support, which can cause issues with rolling off, sitting on the edge of the bed, or for sleepers that are of a heavier size
  • While most consumers are satisfied with the way their Casper mattress performs, some have noted that while sleeping with a partner the mattress has a tendency to lean to one side
  • While reviewers boast about the perfect firmness to softness ratio, some have reported that the mattress wears down quickly, losing its medium-firm feel in as little as 6 months

tuft and needle mattress review

What Do Reviewers Love About Tuft and Needle?

Reviewers also boast about the overall comfort and softness to firmness ratio of the Tuft and Needle mattress. Many reviewers have made appoint to note that they suffer from ailments such as arthritis or chronic back and neck pain. After switching to the Tuft and Needle mattress, they have noticed that their pain has either greatly lessened or completely disappeared.

Overall Pros

  • Tuft and Needle offers a good trial period and warranty
  • The tuft and Needle mattress company cares about their communities, donating mattresses to charity and holds regular school fundraising programs
  • Reviewers note that the mattress is extremely comfortable and help dramatically lessen pain and stiffness
  • Tuft and Needles mattresses offer high-quality at an affordable price

What Are The Drawbacks Of Tuft and Needle?

While the majority of reviewers love the overall comfort of their Tuft and Needle mattress, a large percentage of consumers have reported that the mattress is too soft for them. It doesn’t relieve pressure points well and isn’t compatible with all sleeping positions.

Overall Cons

  • Some reviewers have reported a lingering odor of chemicals, upwards of 2 weeks
  • A large percentage of consumers have noted that despite the temperature regulation measures, the mattress does not sleep cool
  • Users have reported a significant sinking feeling on the Tuft and Needle mattress

Warranty: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

While there are certainly many things you’ll want to take into consideration when shopping for your new mattress, you don’t want to forget about the warranty that’s going to come with it. Before you’ve even made your purchase, it’s important to note that a good warranty often correlates to high-quality. A company will back up a product that they trust. After you’ve purchased your new mattress, you want to make sure that you’re not going to be left footing the bill for a new mattress in 6 months if the one you purchased breaks down prematurely.

So, looking at the warranties of Tuft and Needle vs Casper, whose warranty offers you the best protection?

tuft and needle vs casper mattress

Casper Warranty

When the 5 individuals founded Casper, they were determined to offer buyers the opportunity to try before they buy. So, when you purchase a new mattress from Casper, you get a 100-night risk-free sleep trial. If you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase within the 100-night trial period, Casper will give you a full refund and pick the mattress back up themselves.

If you love your new Casper mattress and decide to keep it after the trial period is over, you’re still protected by a 10-year limited warranty through the Casper company. This means that Casper will repair or replace, at their discretion, your mattress if it is damaged due to normal wear, has an indention of greater than 1”, or if the zipper hardware malfunctions.

Like most warranties, Casper will not cover problems that arise due to improper use or strenuous abuse of the mattress. They also will not cover a mattress that has not been purchased from an authorized dealer or any Casper mattress that has been bought used or “as is”.

Tuft and Needle Warranty

The folks at Tuft and Needle mattress company stand behind their products, and they offer a decent warranty and sleep trial period to prove it. Upon purchasing your Tuft and Needle mattress, you get 100 risk-free nights to try it out and determine whether it’s the best mattress for you. If you’re not completely satisfied with your mattress purchase, Tuft and Needle will provide you with a full refund and will even cover the cost of the pickup in the United States, if needed. If you return your mattress within the 100-night trial period, it is most likely that your mattress will be donated to charity.

If you decide you love your new Tuft and Needle mattress after your sleep trial period is over, you’re still protected by a 10-year limited warranty. The Tuft and Needle 10-year warranty is fairly standard. The company will repair or replace your damaged mattress, at their discretion, if it has a noticeable indention of greater than ¾”, any defect that has caused the foam to split or crack, and any flaws in the mattress covering. Tuft and Needle reserve the right to repair or replace only the mattress cover with the current style available, which may differ from the original.

The warranty does not cover wear from normal use, any damage resulting from misuse, any discrepancies in personal comfort or firmness, or individual allergies or sensitivities to the materials used in the mattress. The warranty also does not cover any Tuft and Needle mattress bought from an unauthorized dealer or purchase used or “as is”.

Who Wins?

Truthfully, the Tuft and Needle vs Casper warranties are about the same. They both offer a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty. Both warranties cover virtually the same things. If we look at the fine details though, Tuft and Needle do cover a bit of a smaller indention than Casper does and they specifically note that their returned mattresses are often given to charity.

About The Companies

Of course, when you’re considering which mattress will best fit your individual needs, the details about the company aren’t necessarily the most important factor in your decision. But, it’s never a bad idea to get a bit of info on the company you’re considering making your purchase from. How long have they been in business? What got them started? Have they won any awards or accreditations?

Here we’ll be taking a look at a bit of the company history of Tuft and Needle vs Casper.

Casper

The Casper mattress company was founded in 2014 by 5 individuals that wanted to revolutionize the way that consumers shopped for and purchased mattresses. They didn’t care for the bright, flashy showrooms or the pushy salesmen that you’d find in every box store. So, they decided to cut out the middleman and the middleman cost by creating an online, direct-to-customer mattress company that allowed their consumers to try before they buy.

Casper has been recognized by Good Morning America, The New York Times, and Forbes. They were also named one of the most innovative companies by Fast company in 2017, as well as received Good Housekeeping’s Lab Pick in 2018.

Tuft and Needle

Two college friends, JT Marino and Daehee Park, found themselves in much the same position as the founders of Casper did. They were tired of the average mattress shopping experience. The large box stores with annoying salesmen, bright, fluorescent lights, and a humongous price tag for a mattress that wasn’t even comfortable and couldn’t be returned.

So, in 2012 Marino and Park, with their backgrounds in e-commerce, marketing, and product and software development, founded the Tuft and Needle mattress company. They believe in quality mattresses with a price tag that doesn’t make you scream. Their mattress materials are sourced and constructed in the USA. They use fresh foam and high-quality materials to guarantee a first-rate mattress without all the hassle or the price of a big box store.

So, What’s Our Final Conclusion?

When we consider all of the categories we’ve covered in this review, the Casper mattress ultimately has a slight leg up. While the Tuft and Needle mattress is significantly cheaper, and their warranty does cover a smaller indention as well as donating their returned mattresses to charity, the Casper mattress simply has more to offer in construction, overall comfort, and temperature regulation.

Reviewers were unsatisfied with the level of firmness in the Tuft and Needle as well as its temperature regulating abilities. The Tuft and Needle is certainly a fantastic option for the price. However, the Casper mattress offers a few more high-quality amenities for a price tag that still comes in just over or under $1000.

See also Tuft and Needle vs Purple, Tuft and Needle vs Leesa and Casper vs Nectar