Leesa vs Tuft and Needle: Complete Comparison Buyer’s Guide to the Best Mattress

Summary: This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Leesa vs Tuft and Needle to help you select the best mattress. DisclosureSleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

__________

With all the different options available on the market today, choosing a new mattress can be a hassle. We’ve put together a comprehensive comparison on two popular mattresses, the Leesa vs Tuft and Needle, to help make your decision process a little easier.

Leesa vs Tuft and Needle Highlights

The Leesa mattress offers:

  • 3-layer construction
  • A perforated top layer for a cooling effect
  • A firm base layer to provide stability and support
  • Donates 1 mattress for every 10 purchased to charity

The Tuft and Needle mattress offers:

  • A two-layer minimalistic construction
  • Light foams to reduce heat retention
  • Tuft and Needle adaptive foam to mimic memory foam without the downfalls
  • A price point under $1000, no matter the mattress size.

Now, we’ll dive into our Tuft and Needle vs Leesa comparison and go over all of the fine details in each specific category to help you make the best choice for you and your family.

Construction: What’s Leesa and T&N Made Of?

One of the important things to take into consideration when you’re searching for the best mattress is the materials it’s made of. There are dozens of different materials available that all offer specific and unique qualities.

So, let’s take a look and see who has the better construction out of Leesa vs Tuft and Needle.

Leesa Construction

The Leesa mattress is constructed with 3 different layers of high-quality foam that harness the very best qualities of each individual material.

leesa vs tuft and needle mattress

2” Layer Of Avena Foam – The very top layer of the Leesa mattress is constructed with 2 inches of perforated Avena foam. This layer actually serves two different purposes: It serves as the first layer of soft, luxury directly against your body to ensure that your sleeping surface is comfortable. This layer of Avena foam allows serves as Leesa’s line of defense against heat retention due to the perforations in the foam that allow for optimal airflow.

2” Layer Of Memory Foam – Underneath the layer of Avena foam, and serving as the core of the Leesa mattress, is a 2-inch layer of memory foam. This layer has been specifically constructed to offer you the best qualities that memory foam has to offer: Cradling joint pain and stiffness relief as well as pressure point relief. His memory foam layer is designed to mold around each individual body to provide sleepers with utmost comfort.

6” Core Support Foam – Bringing up the bottom of the Leesa mattress is 6 inches of core support foam. This layer is there to provide you with the firm support that you need from your mattress, as well as providing added stability and overall reinforcement of the entire mattress. Due to the core support layer, you should never experience instability or a sinking feeling when lying on the Leesa.

These three individual layers come together to create one mattress with a luxurious look and feel.

Tuft and Needle Construction

The creators of the Tuft and Needle took a bit of a different approach when creating their mattress. They felt that the multitude of additional layers was unnecessary in a mattress and only bumped up the cost without raising the bar on the quality. They decided that if the material didn’t increase the comfort or airflow of the mattress, then it wouldn’t be included in their product. So, the Tuft and Needle mattresses are constructed of only two high-quality layers.

tuft and needle vs leesa mattress review

Tuft and Needle Adaptive Foam – The top layer of the Tuft and Needle mattress is constructed with fresh-poured adaptive foam specific to Tuft and Needle. This foam has been specifically designed to mold and cradle every individual body without the sinking feeling or heat retention that’s common in its memory foam competitor. It’s made to cradle your joints and pressure points to alleviate pain and stiffness and specially designed with a localized bounce to greatly reduce or eliminate any motion transference.

Supportive Base Foam – The bottom of the Tuft and Needle mattress features a thick layer of supportive base foam. This layer ensures that you’re still getting the firm support that you expect in your mattress and provides the necessary stability and reinforcement of the entire mattress.

The Tuft and Needle mattress features a soft, breathable cover encasing the entire mattress and all of their materials are certified by Certi-PUR US, Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX, and GREENGUARD Gold.

Who Wins?

Both Leesa and Tuft and Needle are constructed with high-quality materials and promise the consumer a sturdy, durable, supportive, and comfortable mattress. But, when we compare Leesa vs Tuft and Needle, we believe that Leesa takes the win in this category. The utilize a few different materials to ensure that you’re getting the best in comfort, joint and pressure point relief, as well as sturdy support.

leesa vs tuft and needle

Temperature Control

Nothing is worse than being left to toss and turn all night due to a hot mattress and wake up feeling less than motivated to take on your day. You want to make sure that your mattress is equipped with the right properties to guarantee that you’re kept cool and comfortable through the entire night.

In Tuft and Needle vs Leesa, who offers the best level of temperature regulation?

Leesa Temperature Control

The makers of Leesa safeguard their mattress against heat retention in a couple of ways. First and foremost, their entire mattress is constructed with high-quality but light foam. This guarantees that no dense materials, like memory foam, will be trapping heat against your body while you sleep.

In addition to this light foam construction, the top layer of the Leesa’s Avena foam has been perforated through over the entire surface of the mattress. These punctures in the foam allow for optimal airflow and breathability against the skin to guarantee that natural body heat can flow away from the body.

Tuft and Needle Temperature Control

The Tuft and Needle mattress also features two lines of defense against heat retention. Their topmost layer of unique Tuft and Needle adaptive foam has been infused with graphite and cooling gel. These infusions are specifically designed to wick away sweat and natural body heat quickly and efficiently to leave you feeling cool, comfortable, and waking refreshed.

In addition to the cool foam layer, Tuft and Needle has utilized their breathable cover to also safeguard against sweaty nights. Their cover is designed to promote the utmost breathability and airflow so that every inch of the Tuft and Needle mattress coming in contact with your skin is guaranteed to never trap heat.

Who Wins?

When we take a look at Tuft and Needle vs Leesa, we believe that Tuft and Needle has the leg up in this category. They both essentially offer two levels of temperature control. However, the top layer of the Tuft and Needle is actually infused with cooling properties, whereas the Leesa only features perforations.

leesa vs tuft and needle mattress review

Overall Comfort: Softness vs Firmness

Perhaps above all else, you want your new mattress to be comfortable. There isn’t necessarily a one-size-fits-all option when it comes to mattress firmness, as each individual is different. However, it’s most common for mattress shoppers to look for something that lands somewhere in the middle, offering firm support and plush comfort.

When we take a look at Leesa vs Tuft and Needle who takes the win in the comfort category?

Leesa Comfort

The Leesa mattress is described as a medium-firm option, which is ideal for most consumers or those that aren’t necessarily sure what level of firmness is best for them. The Leesa rates a 6 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest and 1 being the softest, which truly lands it somewhere in the middle, making it ideal for the common consumer.

It’s important to note that the Leesa is constructed primarily of memory foam in addition to other foam materials, which isn’t necessarily known for its firmness, rather it’s ability to softly cradle and mold to joints and pressure points. However, in conjunction with the bottom layer of core support foam, the Leesa mattress is expected to provide sleepers with a comfortable, supportive sleeping surface, albeit a bit on the soft side for some.

Tuft and Needle Comfort

The Tuft and Needle is described as a medium-firm option, as well. Their unique, high-quality adaptive foam allows for a soft, plush surface that provides the consumer with optimal comfort and joint/pressure point cradling properties. This top layer is a bit on the soft side, but the combination of supportive base layer allows for a level of firmness and support.

Again, the Tuft and Needle mattress won’t fulfill the needs of anyone that’s looking for extreme softness or firmness. But, it does provide a happy medium for those in search of that ideal ratio.

Who Wins?

In the overall comfort of Tuft and Needle vs Leesa, we’re giving the win to Leesa. They’re both medium-firm options and they’ve both been described as a bit on the softer side of things. So, when we consider only their firmness vs softness ratio, they come out fairly equal. However, the Leesa offers an additional layer of memory foam to contribute to overall comfort.

tuft and needle vs leesa mattress

Price: Leesa vs Tuft and Needle

While you certainly want to guarantee that the mattress you’re purchasing will provide you with years of comfort and support, you don’t want to be left breaking the bank either.

When we compared the prices of Leesa vs Tuft and Needle, who offers you the most bang for your buck?

Leesa Pricing

Leesa is a fairly cost-effective option with their queen-size mattress ringing in at under $1000. For a good mattress that comes with the qualities and amenities that the Leesa has to offer, the cost is pretty fair. The prices of the Leesa mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $375
  • Twin XL – $625
  • Full – $730
  • Queen – $845
  • King – $1045
  • California King – $1045

It is important to note that you can upgrade your Leesa mattress from a king to a California king-size at no additional cost.

Tuft and Needle Pricing

The Tuft and Needle mattress is definitely easy on the wallet. With their king-size option coming in at $700, well under $1000. While this mattress does offer a more minimal construction than the Leesa, it’s still equipped with great amenities such as optimal cooling properties and pressure point relief. For the quality you’ll be receiving from the Tuft and Needle, the cost is somewhat astounding.

The prices of the Tuft and Needle mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $325
  • Twin XL – $375
  • Full- $475
  • Queen – $575
  • King – $700
  • California King – $700

Again, note that you can upgrade your Tuft and Needle mattress from a king-size to their California king option at no additional cost.

Who Wins?

When we compare the price of Leesa vs Tuft and Needle, Tuft and Needle takes the win by a landslide. Both companies allow you to upgrade from a king to California king for the same price. However, you can buy the largest mattress available through Tuft and Needle for under $1000. If you opt for a full-size, you can keep your cost under $500.

Pros and Cons of Leesa vs Tuft and Needle

One of the best ways to determine how well your potential new mattress will perform is to take a look at the views, experiences, and opinions of those that have already purchased and use the mattress. You’ll get some first-hand knowledge of the product as well as a good idea out what makes the mattress great, as well as where it causes some concern, all without ever making a purchase.

Below, we’ll take a look at some of the good and bad reviews of the Tuft and Needle vs Leesa.

What Do Reviewers Love About Leesa?

The Leesa mattress certainly is not short on fantastic reviews. But consumers rave the most about the overall comfort they get out of their Leesa purchase. Consumers have noted that no matter what position they sleep in, the Leesa provides them with astounding comfort. Leesa has definitely made good on their promise to provide joint cradling and outstanding pressure point relief. Even consumers that suffer from ailments such as arthritis or chronic pain have posted that they’re able to wake well-rested, rejuvenated, and free of pain and stiffness after sleeping on their Leesa mattress.

leesa vs tuft and needle mattress review

Pros

  • For every 10 Leesa mattresses purchased, the company donates one Leesa mattress to a homeless shelter
  • The Leesa mattress is proudly made in the USA, and their company is owned and operated within the US
  • Because the Leesa is specifically designed to adapt to individual body shapes and sizes, it’s a great option for couples
  • Leesa keeps you protected with a 100-night sleep trial in addition to a 10-year warranty
  • For the quality and amenities that you’ll receive from your Leesa mattress, it comes with a wallet-friendly price tag

What Are The Drawbacks of Leesa?

While reviewers are highly satisfied with the level of comfort they receive from their Leesa mattress, a high number of consumers have noted that the cooling properties leave a lot to be desired. While the Leesa is equipped with temperature control features, many consumers have noticed that it just doesn’t perform up to par. Many users have been left tossing and turning with frequent waking throughout the night because the Leesa mattress simply slept too hot.

Cons

  • If you decide you don’t love your Leesa mattress and opt to return it, you have to ship it back yourself
  • Many consumers have noticed an off-gassing odor that can potentially take up to a few weeks to fully dissipate
  • The Leesa mattress is not equipped with sufficient edge support, leaving you susceptible to rolling off the bed and causing additional wear and sagging if you sit on the edge often
  • Some consumers have claimed that they had to use an additional mattress topper to achieve their ideal level of comfort

What Do Reviewers Love About Tuft and Needle?

The biggest praise received by the Tuft and Needle mattress is the perfect ratio of firmness vs softness. While, of course, it doesn’t perfectly suit every individual need, several consumers have boasted that the Tuft and Needle mattress allows them to achieve the proper neck and spine alignment. This guarantees that even sufferers of chronic neck and back pain are waking feeling rested and pain-free.

tuft and needle vs leesa

Pros

  • The price tag that comes with the Tuft and Needle is extremely affordable and budget-friendly
  • Reviewers rave about the comfort they get out of their Tuft and Needle mattress, alleviated joint and pressure point pain and stiffness
  • The Tuft and Needle company cares greatly about their communities, holding school fundraisers and donating mattresses to charities
  • Tuft and Needle keeps you covered with a good sleep trial period and warranty

What Are The Drawbacks Of Tuft and Needle?

While a large percentage of Tuft and Needle consumers are highly satisfied with the overall comfort and firmness vs softness of their mattress, some reviewers have noted that the mattress is just a bit on the soft side for their taste. They don’t feel like the Tuft and Needle’s pressure relieving properties perform well and complain that the mattress is not compatible with all sleeping positions.

Cons

  • A strong chemical odor has been noted with the Tuft and Needle mattress and can take up to several weeks to fully dissipate
  • A number of Tuft and Needle reviewers have noted that while the mattress is certainly equipped with cooling properties, it doesn’t necessarily perform well
  • Tuft and Needle consumers, especially those of a larger size, have reported a significant sinking feeling

Warranty: Tuft and Needle vs Leesa

A good warranty is an important thing to consider when weighing your mattress options. A good warranty generally correlates to high-quality and you don’t want to be left footing the bill if your mattress breaks down prematurely. Not to mention, a decent sleep trial period allows you to test the product without making any firm decisions.

Who offers the best warranty in Tuft and Needle vs Leesa?

Leesa Warranty

The Leesa company offers a 100-night happiness guarantee. Meaning you get to sleep on your Leesa mattress in your home for 100 nights to ensure that you’re comfortable and satisfied before making any final decisions. If you’re not completely satisfied with your Leesa purchase, you can return it within the 100-night trial period for a full refund. However, you will be responsible for shipping the mattress back.

If you love your Leesa mattress and decide to stick with your purchase, you will remain protected by a 10-year limited warranty. The Leesa warranty is fairly standard and guarantees that the Leesa company will repair or replace your mattress as long as it’s been used in accordance with their warranty terms.

leesa vs tuft and needle

The warranty covers any indention in the mattress that is greater than an inch, any physical defect that compromises the performance of the memory foam, and any flaws or failures in the seam or sipper hardware of the included cover. Note that if the cover is damaged, Leesa will replace it with the current cover in use which may differ in color or design.

The Leesa mattress is specifically designed to be used with a supportive base or frame. Keep in mind that Leesa will not cover any damages incurred from using their mattress with an improper base or frame. The warranty also does not cover any damages sustained by improper use, excessive abuse by the owner, any typical increase in softness that does not affect Leesa’s pressure relieving properties, or any mattress that has been purchased from an unauthorized dealer, or bought “as is”.

Tuft and Needle Warranty

The creators of the Tuft and Needle mattress proudly stand behind their product and offer a decent warranty and sleep trial to prove it. When you purchase your Tuft and Needle mattress, you have 100 nights to decide if you love it. If you decide that the Tuft and Needle isn’t the best choice for you, not only will the company give you a full refund, they will cover the cost of shipping within the Us, and most likely donate your mattress to a local charity.

tuft and needle vs leesa

If you opt to keep your Tuft and Needle mattress after the 100-night sleep trial period, you’re still covered by a 10-year limited warranty. Like most standard limited warranties, Tuft and Needle will repair or replace your mattress at no cost to you if it has a noticeable indention greater than ¾ of an inch, any failure causing the foam to split or crack, or any flaws or defects in the mattress cover. Tuft and Needle also reserve the right to replace the mattress covering with the current one in use, which may differ in design or color.

Like most warranties, Tuft and Needle does not cover any damages resulting from improper use, any issues of personal comfort or firmness, or any individual allergies or sensitivities. As expected, the tuft and Needle warranty does not cover any mattress that is purchased “as is” or from an unauthorized dealer.

Who Wins?

When it comes down to it, the warranties offered by Leesa vs Tuft and Needle are both fairly standard. However, Tuft and Needle get the leg up because they will cover the cost of shipping the mattress back if you’re not satisfied within the 100-night trial period.

About The Companies

While the history of the company may not make or break your decision, it’s never a bad idea to get a bit of information such as how they got their start, how long they’ve been in business, and if they’ve won any awards or accreditations.

Let’s have a look at the history of Leesa vs Tuft and Needle.

About Leesa

The founders of the Leesa mattress company found themselves highly unsatisfied when it came to the typical mattress buying process. They found it to be far too complicated and the prices way too high. So, they set out to create a mattress company that cut out the hustle and bustle of the buying process as well as all the middleman prices and markups, allowing customers to buy a high-quality, budget-friendly mattress less all the fuss.

The creators of Leesa set out to leave behind a better world. The company has expressly stated that they are just as concerned about their social and environmental impact as they are with their profits and revenue. Because of this attitude, the Leesa company has always and will continue to, hold school fundraisers in their local communities, donate 1 mattress for every 10 sold to homeless shelters, and plant trees to reduce their carbon footprint.

About Tuft and Needle

The Tuft and Needle mattress company was founded in 2012 by two college friends, JT Marino and Daehee Park when they found themselves in much the same position as the founder of Leesa. They were sick and tired of the big box mattress buying experience. So, with backgrounds in e-commerce, marketing, and product and software development, they created a mattress company that skips the florescent lighting and pushy salesmen and instead provides consumers with a high-quality, budget-friendly mattress.

They source all their materials and construct their mattresses exclusively in the USA and only use fresh foam and high-quality materials to guarantee you’re buying a mattress you can be proud of.

So, What’s Our Final Conclusion?

Both Tuft and Needle and Leesa offer a high-quality mattress at an affordable price. However, based on our comparison of Leesa vs Tuft and Needle, Tuft and Needle take the win. They won more of our categories, such as temperature control and warranty and they offer consumers a cool, comfortable mattress for under $1000.

So, if you’re looking for a mattress that will keep you supported, cradle your joints and pressure points, and still keep your bank account safe, the Tuft and Needle mattress is a fantastic option.