Loom and Leaf vs Casper: A Complete Comparison Buyer’s Guide To The Best Mattress

This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Loom and Leaf vs Casper to help you select the best mattress. DisclosureSleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

__________

Loom and Leaf vs Casper Highlights

The Casper mattress offers:

  • Courteous and timely customer service representatives
  • A perfect firmness level verified by real-life customer reviews
  • Temperature regulating technology throughout every layer
  • An industry-standard sleep trial and limited warranty
  • A 4-layer hybrid combination of high-quality memory foam and latex

The Loom and Leaf mattress offers:

  • 5-layer hybrid construction featuring high-quality materials
  • High-quality, stable foam that ensures no off-gassing
  • Industry-leading cooling properties throughout the entire mattress
  • 2 firmness level options to fit every individual need
  • Construction and feel comparable to Tempurpedic without the price tag

Purchasing a new mattress can be a difficult decision to make. While we can’t hand-pick your new mattress for you, we do set out to make the process a bit easier.

Here, we’ve compiled a comprehensive review of Loom and Leaf vs Casper, two popular mattress options available on the market today, to see which will best fit your needs.

Construction: What’s It Made Out Of?

Let’s take a look at the construction of Casper vs Loom and Leaf to see which mattress offers the highest quality and best benefits.

casper vs loom and leaf mattress comparison

Casper Construction

The makers of the Casper mattress set out to combine the very best qualities that memory foam and latex have to offer in one top-notch, four-layer hybrid mattress.

Breathable Memory Foam

Casper tops their mattress with a layer of breathable memory foam for optimal comfort directly against the body. Like conventional memory foam, this layer is designed to mold and cradle every individual body shape and size to provide all of the joint pain and pressure point relief that consumers have come to expect from memory foam material.

However, Casper formulates their memory foam with an open cell construction. That way, unlike its conventional counterpart, Casper’s memory foam still remains breathable and cool.

Pressure Relieving Memory Foam

Underneath their layer of open-cell, breathable memory foam is an additional layer of pressure relieving memory foam. The makers of Casper specifically designed this layer to guarantee that their customers are truly getting all the best that memory foam has to offer.

This layer is made to provide deep pressure relief, cradling joints and pressure points through the layer above to ensure that you’re getting the comfort and relief that one simple layer of memory foam cannot give.

Zoned Support Memory Foam

Casper has made sure that their comfort doesn’t skimp on support. To do so, they’ve equipped the third layer of their mattress with zoned support memory foam. The Casper company has tried to ensure that their customers are getting the just-right level soft comfort and supportive firmness in all the correct places.

Under areas such as the lower back and neck, they’ve added firmer memory foam to help ensure proper alignment and support while areas under the hips and shoulders are softer to avoid numbness and pain.

Supportive Latex Foam

Serving as the foundation of the Casper mattress is a layer of thick, supportive latex foam. This layer serves two purposes: To guarantee that Casper users are getting the crucial support that they need as well as reinforcing the entire mattress and ensuring that you’re getting the best performance possible out of the above layers.

The makers of the Casper mattress have expertly combined these materials into one high-quality, comfortable, and supportive mattress.

loom and leaf vs casper

Loom and Leaf Construction

Loom and Leaf has made it their mission to provide their customers with unsurpassed comfort, support, and temperature regulation.

Organic, Quilted Cotton Cover

Loom and Leaf has enclosed their entire mattress in a breathable, organic, quilted cotton cover. L&L produces their cover with all-organic cotton that’s been quilted to perfection to ensure that the material closest to your skin is cool, comfortable, and luxuriously soft to the touch. They also promise to keep you safe with the addition of all-natural thistle flame retardant that meets all safety and flammability standards without the use of harsh or harmful chemicals.

Cooling Spinal Gel

The top layer of the actual Loom and Leaf mattress is equipped with 2 inches of proprietary cooling spinal gel. Loom and Leaf’s exclusive gel is designed to keep you as cool as possible throughout the night as well as ensure proper spine and neck alignment.

They use a superior swirling technique within their gel to guarantee that the entire mattress surface stays cool and comfortable as well as add additional support under the lumbar region. This technique helps to ensure proper alignment and also serves as an additional line of defense against heat retention in an area of the body that is known to produce a lot of heat.

Premium Foam

The core of the Loom and Leaf mattress is made of 5lbs of eco-friendly premium foam. Loom and Leaf has designed this layer to provide all of the joint cradling and pressure point relief that customers have come to expect from memory foam material.

But, unlike many of their competitors, L&L has made sure their foam is 100% safe for their customers and our environment. L&L foam is made completely in the USA and is always delivered whole and stable. They also guarantee that their foam materials are naturally cool and do not produce any off-gassing odors.

Breathable Support Foam

Up next is a dual layer of breathable, eco-friendly support foam. Loom and Leaf utilize this layer to make sure that their customers are getting the necessary level of support that they need from their mattress – providing firmness and stability through their layers of memory foam.

They also mold channels throughout the support foam material to add another layer of cooling properties, allowing for adequate circulation of fresh air.

Support Base Layer

Of course, the Loom and Leaf mattress is equipped with a supportive base layer. Like all mattresses, especially those primarily constructed of foam, Loom and Leaf’s base layer is designed to provide stability, support, and enhance the properties of the above layers.

Who Wins?

We certainly believe that both companies construct their mattresses with high-quality materials and craftsmanship. But, when it comes to Casper vs Loom and Leaf, we think that Loom and Leaf has the edge. They equip their mattresses with proprietary materials, combine necessary support with luxurious comfort, and feature 5 individual layers.

Temperature Control

In this category, we’ll compare the temperature control infused in Loom and Leaf vs Casper to see which mattress will keep you the coolest and most comfortable throughout the night no matter the conditions.

casper vs loom and leaf comparison

Casper Temperature Control

The Casper company ensures that every inch of their mattress is working hard to keep you cool. As we noted in our construction section above, the top layer of the Casper mattress features memory foam that’s been created with an open-cell formula.

This special formulation harnesses the powers of convection and conduction to actually draw in heat and move it away from the body quickly and efficiently.

Even the layer of memory foam underneath the topmost layer is designed with cooling properties in mind. This layer works in conjunction with the layer above to pull heat further away from the top layer to guarantee that no heat is trapped against the body during the night. It also provides adequate airflow and breathability to allow for fresh air circulation.

To wrap things up, the bottom latex layer of the Casper mattress is also designed to help keep you cool. This layer has been specifically designed to absorb any heat that’s been drawn down through the top layers and disperse it evenly through the bottom of the mattress to ensure that it’s far away from the skin.

loom and leaf vs casper

Loom and Leaf Temperature Control

Like their Casper counterpart, the Loom and Leaf mattress is equipped with cooling technology throughout every inch. To start, they guarantee that the material closest to your skin every night is soft, cool, and comfortable. By using 100% all-natural organic cotton,

L&L guarantees that their cover will quickly wick away heat and sweat, keeping you cool and dry while remaining soft and plush to the touch.

Directly underneath their natural cotton cover is their layer of proprietary cooling spinal gel. Unlike many of their competitors, this layer of the L&L mattress combats heat retention in a few different ways, all in and of itself.

Their exclusive gel swirl technique allows the cooling technology to be dispersed evenly throughout the surface and lending the top of the mattress a cooling sensation. They also employ an inverted foam tip design that allows for optimal breathability, airflow, and circulation.

Lastly, L&L has laminated an additional panel of cooling spinal gel under the lumbar region to specifically target one of the most heat-prone areas of the body. Their official website also notes that they only use 100% pure cooling gel that is usually only used in hospitals or other medical settings to ensure that you’re getting the highest quality and safety.

All of their eco-friendly memory foam is designed to remain breathable and neutral in temperature. Their dual support layer is equipped with cooling properties as well. It’s been specially designed with molded channels throughout the layer to improve breathability, airflow, and adequate circulation of fresh air.

Who Wins?

Both mattress companies equip their product with cooling technology in pretty much every layer. But, when we compare the safeguards in Loom and Leaf vs Casper, we feel that Loom and Leaf takes the win. Just one of their layers fights off heat retention in three separate ways and a lot of their technology is proprietary or even medical-grade.

Overall Comfort: Firmness vs Softness

In this category, we’ll take a look at the firmness vs softness ratio as well as the overall comfort offered by Casper vs Loom and Leaf.

casper vs loom and leaf comparison

Casper Comfort

Casper is as a medium-firm mattress. This is the most common option for consumers and also serves as a great starting place for those that aren’t necessarily sure on their desired firmness level yet.

Their mattress is primarily constructed with memory foam materials. Memory foam is well known for its ability to mold to the body, cradle joints, and relieve numbness and pressure point areas. However, memory foam is not usually known for its ability to provide firmness, support, or stability.

But, Casper has found a way around this common memory foam issue. Their latex base ensures that consumers will always get the firm support and stability that they’re looking for without skimping on the comfort and relief that memory foam has to offer.

loom and leaf vs casper mattress

Loom and Leaf Comfort

The makers of the Loom and Leaf mattress take the comfort of their customers to heart. That’s why their mattress is available in two different comfort levels to ensure that most everyone can get the correct level or firmness vs softness that they desire in their mattress.

Their mattress is available in the Loom and Leaf Relaxed Firm version – which rates a 6 on the firmness scale and has been painstakingly designed to provide the perfect ratio of comfort and support. If you happen to be someone that prefers a firmer mattress feel, L&L has you covered as well with their Loom and Leaf Firm option – rated at an 8 on the firmness scale to provide an extra layer of support and stability.

Both versions of the Loom and Leaf mattress feature high-quality materials, first-rate craftsmanship, and comfortable support. According to the Loom and Leaf website, their relaxed firm version is best equipped for all sleeping positions or those that have a tendency to switch positions often throughout the night. Their L&L firm version is recommended for back and stomach sleepers as it provides the ideal level of support and proper alignment.

Who Wins?

Both companies have created a mattress that’s supportive yet comfortable. But, in Loom and Leaf vs Casper, we’re giving the win to Loom and Leaf. L&L has designed their mattress with comfort and support in mind and even offers two different firmness levels to best accommodate the most customers.

Price: Loom and Leaf vs Casper

Let’s take a look at the prices of Loom and Leaf vs Casper to see which mattress will give you the most bang for your buck.

casper vs loom and leaf

Casper Price

The Casper mattress features lots of great benefits and amenities. Considering that their queen-size mattress comes in at just a few dollars under $1000, it doesn’t come in at a bad price point either.

The prices of the Casper mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $595
  • Twin XL – $645
  • Full – $895
  • Queen – $995
  • King – $1195
  • California King – $1195

We also noted that you can upgrade your purchase from a king-size to a California king at no additional cost.

loom and leaf vs casper

Loom and Leaf Price

Considering the average prices of a high-quality mattress these days, the Loom and Leaf mattress comes in at a fairly neutral price point. Their queen-size mattress is just a bit over $1000 and even their largest option come in under $1500.

The prices of the Loom and Leaf mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $749
  • Twin XL – $799
  • Full – $999
  • Queen – $ 1099
  • King – $1499
  • California King – $1499

It’s apparent that the Loom and Leaf mattress isn’t the cheapest option on the market. But, considering that their mattress is supposed to rival the likes of Tempurpedic, the L&L company feels that their price is a fair equation to their quality. You can upgrade from a king to a California king-size at no additional cost and Loom and Leaf does offer to finance their product through Klarna.

Who Wins?

It’s pretty easy to see that when it comes to the price of Casper vs Loom and Leaf, that Casper takes the win in this category. Their mattress is available in any size for under $1500.

Pros & Cons Of Casper vs Loom and Leaf

Here, we’ll be covering a few of the best, as well as a few of the not-so-great reviews we found on Casper vs Loom and Leaf.

casper vs loom and leaf

What Do Reviewers Love About Casper?

A quick glance at the review section definitely proves that customers love their Casper mattress. But, above all else, reviewers rave about the perfect softness to firmness ratio. The official website makes it clear that the designers were determined to make the most comfortable and supportive mattress and it seems that they’ve made good on that promise.

As a matter of fact, a large handful of reviewers have even noted that many of their pain and stiffness symptoms have been greatly reduced after sleeping on their Casper mattress.

Pros

  • The Casper company protects your purchase with an industry-standard warranty and sleep trial period
  • Many reviewers have raved that Casper’s customer service department is friendly and timely
  • Casper equips every layer of their mattress with cooling technology
  • Reviewers claim that the Casper mattress boasts the perfect balance of firmness and softness
  • Casper features dozens of amenities and benefits at a fairly budget-friendly price

What Are The Downfalls Of Casper?

Casper’s biggest complaint doesn’t have anything to do with the performance of the mattress, rather the off-gassing odor that so many reviewers have noticed. Like many online, direct-to-consumer mattresses, the Casper mattress is compressed in plastic for quicker and cheaper shipping.

Because of this packaging process, the foam can accumulate an odor. Upon breaking the seal of the packaging, an off-gassing odor is released. While it’s not uncommon, it should usually dissipate in 48-72 hours. However, many Casper users have noticed that their mattress still smells up to 2-3 weeks later.

Cons

  • The Casper mattress lacks adequate edge support leaving you susceptible to rolling off and causing premature wear
  • A handful of reviewers have complained that their Casper mattress broke down in as little as 6 months
  • It can take the Casper mattress up to 72-hours to fully expand and be ready for use
  • Some users have noticed that, when sleeping with a partner, their Casper mattress has a tendency to lean to one side

loom and leaf vs casper

What Do Reviewers Love About Loom and Leaf?

Much like their Casper competitor, the Loom and Leaf mattress is well known for its astounding level of comfort. The L&L official website claims that their mattress is comparable to the Tempurpedic. According to several reviewers, they would have to agree.

In fact, many customers have actually made the switch from Tempurpedic to Loom and Leaf and find that they’re just as satisfied, if not more so, with their Loom and Leaf purchase. Users claim that their Loom and Leaf mattress provides them with the best night’s sleep they’ve ever had without the staggering price tag of the Tempurpedic.

Pros

  • Loom and Leaf tries to ensure that everyone can afford their product by offering to finance through Klarna
  • L&L offers a free white glove service and mattress removal
  • Their mattress is equipped with sufficient edge support to guarantee you’re not left rolling off or causing premature damage
  • L&L mattresses are never compressed and guaranteed to never cause any off-gassing odors
  • L&L uses high-quality materials to ensure there is little to no motion transference
  • Loom and Leaf offers different mattress options that are compatible with any sleeping position

What Are The Downfalls Of Loom and Leaf?

We had a very difficult time finding any complaints about the Loom and Leaf mattress. Virtually everyone seemed to be completely satisfied. But, we did notice a few reviews complaining that the mattress was still a bit form for their liking, even with the relaxed option.

Cons

  • It is possible that you will notice harmless, natural marking in their organic cotton cover
  • The use of heating blankets or heating pads can cause the memory foam to become softer than usual
  • L&L recommends using their entire system instead of a conventional box spring set up – though it’ not required by their warranty
  • L&L manufactures their mattresses to order so shipping can take a significant amount of time

Warranty: Casper vs Loom and Leaf

Below, we’ll be comparing the warranties offered by Loom and Leaf vs Casper to see which company will keep your purchase best protected.

casper vs loom and leaf

Casper Warranty

Casper keeps your purchase protected with an industry-standard warranty and sleep trial. Upon purchasing your Casper mattress, you get to use the product in your own home for 100 nights before you’re required to make any final decision. If you don’t completely love your purchase, you can return it for a full refund and Casper will even arrange to have the mattress picked up from your home.

If you love your Casper and decide to keep it after the sleep trial period is over, you’re still protected for the next 10 years of ownership. Like most limited warranties, for the next 10 years, Casper will repair or replace your mattress provided that the damage meets the term of their warranty. Of course, Casper is not responsible for damages incurred from improper use or abuse.

Loom and Leaf Warranty

The Loom and Leaf mattress company knows that you simply can’t decide if you’re satisfied with a mattress with a 10-minute “sleep trial” in the store. So, they offer their customers a 120-night sleep trial period to allow their customers adequate time to make a truly informed decision.

If you find that you’re not happy with your purchase, L&L will issue a full refund, less a $99 transportation cost. We could not find for certain if Loom and Leaf would remove the mattress from your home. But, they do offer free white glove service and mattress removal upon purchase. So, we think it’s safe to assume they will.

After the 120-night trial period is up, L&L offers their customers a 15-year limited warranty. If you use the warranty within the first 2 years, they will repair or replace your mattress at no cost to you. For the next 13 years, you will be responsible for a $99 transportation fee.

Loom and Leaf also offer a different warranty option called the “Fairness Replacement Option”. With this warranty, you will get to keep your original mattress no matter what. During years 3-5 of your warranty, they will bring a new mattress and set it up in your home for 30% of your original purchase price. Years 6-10 will be prorated at 50% and the remainder at 75%.

Like all warranties, Loom and Leaf does not cover damage incurred from misuse or abuse or any mattress purchased “as is” or from an unauthorized dealer.

Who Wins?

Both companies offer decent warranties on their products. When comparing Casper vs Loom and Leaf, Loom and Leaf barely takes the win. Their sleep trial period is a bit longer as well as their warranty. But they do charge an additional $99 transportation fee and their fairness warranty prorates your original cost.

About The Companies

Let’s dive into a few of the important details surrounding the Casper vs Loom and Leaf companies.

casper vs loom and leaf

Casper

The founders of the Casper mattress company found themselves in the same position as many online mattress company founders. They were sick and tired of the way people were expected to buy a new mattress.

In 2014, 5 folks came together to create a solution to this common problem. They cut out the middleman process as well as the middleman cost and created an online-only, direct-to-consumer mattress company that would provide high-quality, affordable mattresses to every average family.

Since their founding in 2014, the Casper company has been recognized by Forbes, the New York Times, and Good Morning America. They also received Good Housekeeping’s 2018 Lab Pick and were recognized as one of the most innovative companies by Fast Company in 2017.

loom and leaf

Loom and Leaf

The Loom and Leaf mattress company came to be thanks to the success of their mother company, Saatva, which produces innerspring mattresses. Like most mattress companies these days, they wanted to reinvent the way we buy mattresses.

Loom and Leaf wanted to provide customers with high- quality and unsurpassed comfort without all of the hassle and marked up prices. That’s why they’ve grown from a small regional company to America’s largest online-only mattress company.

Loom and Leaf has worked hard to ensure that their mattress is as eco-friendly as possible without all of the astronomical prices that come with organic and all-natural production. They have donated hundreds of mattresses over the years and partnered with dozens of high need charities across the country such as the Wounded Warrior Project, Seeds Of Hope, and St. Mary’ s Children’s Hospital.

What’s The Final Conclusion Of Our Comparison Review?

We’re definitely impressed with both mattresses we’ve reviewed here. They both offer high-quality construction, temperature controlling technology throughout the entire mattress, and decent warranties to protect your purchase. But, when it comes down between Loom and Leaf vs Casper, we think that Loom and Leaf takes the overall win this time.

Loom and Leaf offers unsurpassed comfort that rivals the likes of Tempurpedic, industry-leading cooling technology throughout the entire mattress, and a 15-year warranty all at a price tag that doesn’t make you want to scream. Plus, they’re happy to finance your purchase to help ensure that everyone can afford a great mattress.

_________

See also: Loom and Leaf vs Leesa.