Puffy vs Casper: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide to the Best Mattress

Summary: This in-depth, unbiased guide is a Sleeping Ninjas showdown between Puffy vs Casper Mattress to help you select the best mattress. DisclosureSleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.

__________

Puffy vs Casper Highlights

The Puffy mattress offers:

  • Free shipping guaranteed within 2-5 days
  • 101- night sleep trial period and lifetime warranty
  • Complete compatibility with any flat surface, including the floor
  • Cooling Cloud Foam top layer that promises an all-night cool sleep
  • Adaptable foam construction that guarantees all-over comfort

The Casper mattress offers:

  • An industry-standard warranty and sleep trial period to guarantee that your purchase remains protected
  • A perfect ratio of softness to firmness verified by real-life customer reviews
  • A timely, friendly, and courteous customer service department
  • Temperate controlling technology ingrained in every layer
  • A 4-layer memory foam and latex hybrid construction

Choosing a new mattress can be a difficult decision to make. There are so many different options available on the market these days, it can be difficult to even know where to start.

That’s why we’ve compiled a complete comparison review of Puffy vs Casper, two popular options on the market today, to help you determine which mattress is the very best fit for you. Let’s dive in!

Construction: What’s It Made Out Of?

To kick off our Puffy vs Casper comparison review, let’s take a look at the overall construction of the mattresses to see just exactly what they’re made of.

 

Puffy Construction

The puffy mattress features a minimalistic, 2-layer hybrid construction that’s specially engineered to guarantee that you’re getting more for less.puffy vs casper mattress

4” Cooling Cloud Foam Top Layer

The Puffy company spent four years studying, testing, and researching to produce the award-winning material featured in their top layer of Cooling Cloud Foam. This layer has been perfectly designed to keep users cool and comfortable. The material performs much like memory foam, cradling joints and pressure points and providing unsurpassed comfort and gentle support in all the right places.

This top layer is also where you’ll find Puffy’s temperature regulating properties. The proprietary Cooling Cloud Foam is designed to provide optimal breathability and airflow directly against the body to ensure that you’re never left tossing and turning due to a too hot mattress.

6” Firm Core Support Base Layer

Underneath their layer of patented Cooling Cloud Foam is their 6-inch layer of firm support foam. This layer has been bonded to the top layer to guarantee optimal support and stability throughout the mattress. This base layer reinforces and enhances the layer above and ensures that you’re never left with a too-soft surface that’s lacking in proper support or firmness. It also increases the overall durability of the product and guarantees that the mattress is compatible with a variety of different bases.

Casper Construction

The Casper mattress is a hybrid option that combines the best qualities of memory foam and latex into four individual layers, promising their customers the very best in both support and comfort.

casper vs puffy mattress comparison

Breathable Memory Foam

The top layer of the Casper mattress is equipped with super-breathable, high-quality memory foam. Casper specially formulates their memory foam with a unique open-cell construction that allows the material to breathe and promote airflow, unlike its conventional counterpart. This way, users can reap all the fantastic benefits of memory foam, like joint cradling and pressure relief, without the common heat retention.

Pressure Relieving Memory Foam

Up next is a layer of Casper’s high-quality pressure relieving memory foam. This layer is where you’ll find all of the fantastic benefits you’ve come to expect from memory foam material. This layer is designed to mold around joints and pressure points for cradling comfort and relief of pain, stiffness, and numbness.

Zoned Support Memory Foam

The third layer of the Casper mattress is constructed with their zoned support memory foam and serves as their last layer of memory foam material. Casper has designed this layer with specific areas of softness and firmness to guarantee that users are getting the correct level of support and comfort in all the right places. It also helps promote proper alignment and increases pressure relief.

Supportive Latex Foam

Bringing up the bottom of the Casper mattress is their base layer of supportive latex foam. This high-quality latex layer reinforces the entire mattresses, enhances the performance of the layers above, and adds extra durability thanks to the latex material. It also helps to ensure that users are getting all the necessary support, firmness, and stability out of their Casper mattress.

Who Wins?

While we appreciate the minimalistic approach taken by the Puffy company, when it comes to the overall construction of Casper vs Puffy, Casper ultimately takes the win in this category. They construct their mattress with more layers and combine two high-quality materials to ensure that their users are getting the very best.

Temperature Control

Up next, let’s take a look at the temperature control offered by Puffy vs Casper to see which mattress will keep you the coolest all throughout the night.

puffy vs casper

Puffy Temperature Control

The Puffy mattress utilizes its topmost layer to ensure that you’re as cool and comfortable as possible throughout the night. Puffy has designed their proprietary Cooling Cloud Foam to perform the same as conventional memory foam when it comes to conforming and cradling properties. But they’ve ensured that their design will never retain heat.

Their Cooling Cloud Foam harnesses the powers of convection and conduction to optimize airflow and breathability directly against the body. It’s guaranteed to always remain neutral in temperature and the Puffy company boasts that their cooling gel infusion actually draws away heat and increases overall airflow at 8x’s the rate of conventional foam options.

casper vs puffy

Casper Temperature Control

Casper has taken the cooling properties of their mattress very seriously. Unlike many other options on the market that only equip the first layer or two of their products with heat retention safeguards, Casper has utilized every single inch.

The top layer is equipped with open-cell formula foam that uses the power of convection and conduction to actually pull heat away from your body as you sleep. The layer of memory foam directly beneath is designed to promote breathability and airflow as well as draw heat down and away from the top layer to ensure that it’s far from the skin as you sleep.

Even the very bottom layer of durable latex foam is working hard to keep you cool. This layer absorbs the heat that’s drawn down from the top layers and distributes it evenly through the bottom of the mattress.

Who Wins?

We’re certain that the Puffy mattress makes good on its promise to keep its users cool and comfortable through the night. But, when it comes to the temperature control category of Casper vs Puffy, we’re giving the win to Casper. Casper utilizes every layer of their mattress to keep you cool while Puffy has only equipped their topmost layer.

Overall Comfort: Softness vs Firmness

In this category of our Puffy vs Casper comparison review, we’ll be covering the overall comfort as well as the firmness to softness ratio of both mattresses.

puffy mattress vs casper

Puffy Comfort

The Puffy company has worked hard to guarantee that their customers are as comfortable and supported as possible. Some companies, like Puffy’s counterpart Casper, equip their mattresses with zoned support – specific areas of softness and firmness that correlates with where your body will lie on the mattress. While this isn’t a bad tactic at all, it does leave users confined to a certain area of the mattress to fully reap the benefits.

Puffy combats this issue by equipping their mattress with their adaptable foam, making it a great option for any body shape or size. This guarantees that no matter your height or weight, or even if you significantly differ in size from your sleeping partner, every Puffy user will experience complete, adaptable comfort.

Puffy has also guaranteed that their users will experience completely adaptable support as well. Their base layer is equipped with Insta-Firm Technology that’s designed to adapt accordingly to the pressure put on the mattress. This guarantees that no matter your size, the Puffy mattress will provide optimal alignment, gentle support, and crucial stability.

In fact, the Puffy mattress promises to provide 99% better responsiveness and 4x the bounce-back of a standard mattress. This combination of high-quality materials guarantees that Puffy customers will get the absolute best in both comfort and support.

casper vs puffy comparison

Casper Comfort

The Casper mattress is marketed as a medium-firm option, which is most popular among consumers and a great option for those that aren’t certain on their firmness preferences yet. You will notice in our construction section above that the Casper mattress is primarily constructed of memory foam material. Memory foam is certainly well known for it’s cradling and pressure relieving abilities, but it usually skimps on firmness and support.

Casper has found a way around this issue by equipping their mattress with affirm base layer of latex foam. This guarantees that their users can enjoy all those great benefits of memory foam while still remaining supported and stable. This combination allows the Casper mattress to provide its users with the best of both worlds.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the comfort offered by Casper vs Puffy, we’re giving Puffy the win in this category. Both mattresses ensure that their customers are both comfortable and well supported. But, you’ll note in our construction section that Casper utilizes zoned support while Puffy equips their mattress with adaptable foam that allows for complete comfort and support from edge to edge.

Price: Puffy vs Casper

Below, we’ll compare the prices of the Puffy vs Casper mattresses to see which option offers the most bang for your buck.

Puffy Price

The Puffy company offers two different options, the Puffy and the Puffy Lux. The Puffy Lux does feature a few added amenities which bump up the cost some.

The pricing of the Puffy and Puffy Lux are as follows:

Puffy

  • Twin – $625
  • Twin XL – $675
  • Full – $795
  • Queen – $995
  • King & California King – $1195

Puffy Lux

  • Twin – $1245
  • Twin XL – $1295
  • Full – $1395
  • Queen – $1595
  • King & California King – $1795

All in all, the Puffy mattress is neither the cheapest nor the most expensive mattress on the market. But, the product is made with high-quality materials and promises users the very best in comfort, support, and temperature control. So, in the end, both the Puffy and Puffy Lux have pretty average price tags.

casper vs puffy

Casper Price

The Casper mattress comes in at a pretty fair price with their queen-size option ringing up at just a hair under the $1000 mark and their larger sizes just over.

The prices of the Casper mattress are as follows:

  • Twin – $595
  • Twin XL – $645
  • Full – $895
  • Queen – $995
  • King – $1195
  • California King – $1195

Like their Puffy counterpart, the Casper mattress is somewhere around the middle when it comes to the average price of a new mattress. But, considering all the benefits and amenities such as a high-quality 4-layer construction and complete temperature regulation throughout the layers, the price of the Casper mattress certainly isn’t terrible.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the price section of Casper vs Puffy, Casper just barely has the leg up. Both mattresses are the same price for their queen-size and larger options. But, the smaller sizes of the Casper mattress are just a little bit cheaper. Plus, the Puffy gets much more expensive if you do decide to upgrade to the Puffy Lux.

Pros & Cons Of Casper vs Puffy

Here, let’s take a look at some of the reviews of Puffy vs Casper to see what their best selling points are as well as a few of their most common issues.

What Do Users Love About Puffy?

Perhaps the biggest praise we noticed for the Puffy mattress was its unsurpassed joint cradling and pressure relieving abilities, especially for side and back sleepers. Customers have noted that Puffy makes good on its promise to provide optimal comfort, gentle support, and relieve pain, pressure, and stiffness in the most common problem areas.

According to reviews, users are getting a solid, restful night’s sleep without tossing and turning and are able to wake every morning with little to no discomfort or pain. Some users have even noted that they do roll onto their stomach occasionally and still sleep comfortable and wake pain-free.

Pros

  • Customers claim that the Puffy mattress provides the perfect ratio of softness to firmness
  • Many users say that they’ve made the switch from traditional memory foam and their Puffy mattress actually performs better
  • The adaptable foam allows for very little to no motion transference throughout the night
  • Many compressed foam options can take 72 hours to fully expand, but the Puffy expands and is ready for use in as little as 60 seconds
  • The Puffy company keeps your purchase protected with a lifetime warranty

What Are The Common Downfalls Of Puffy?

The biggest complaint we noticed about the Puffy mattress was the adjustment period. The Puffy company utilizes a special material that is only available in their product. Because of this new, different material, it can take your body several weeks, up to 30-days, to adjust to your new Puffy mattress. During this period, you may experience some discomfort or even pain until your body has acclimated to the new surface.

Cons

  • The Puffy mattress is recommended for back and side sleepers and may not be comfortable for those that primarily sleep on their stomach
  • Some users have actually complained that the surface of the Puffy mattress is a bit too cool for their taste
  • The Puffy company does not offer a white glove service to assist with set up
  • Customers have noted that the Puffy mattress is quite heavy and difficult to maneuver/set up on your own

casper vs puffy

What Do Users Love About Casper?

While it’s easy to see that users love their Casper mattress, their biggest commendation seems to lie in their perfect ratio of softness to firmness. The makers of the Casper mattress made it their mission to ensure that their customers both comfortable and supported and it seems that they’ve made good on that promise.

Several reviewers have even noted that they suffer from pain-inducing ailments such as arthritis or fibromyalgia and their Casper mattress has greatly reduced or even completely eliminated their nightly symptoms and allowed them to wake without pain and stiffness.

Pros

  • Customers rave that Casper’s customer service department is friendly, timely, and courteous
  • Casper’s level of firmness vs softness is virtually unsurpassed
  • Every single layer of the Casper mattress is equipped with temperature regulating properties
  • The Casper company offers an industry-standard sleep trial and warranty
  • The Casper mattress is available at a fairly average price point

What Are The Common Downfalls Of Casper?

While we didn’t find a lot of complaints about the performance of the Casper mattress, several users did complain about the smell. Foam mattresses are commonly compressed and vacuum-sealed for shipping which can cause “fresh foam” odors to become trapped. It’s not unusual for this smell to linger for a couple of days. But, many Casper users have unfortunately noted that the odor is still in the mattress months later.

Cons

  • Some users have complained that their Casper mattress broke down in as little as 6 months
  • Customers have noticed that the mattress tends to lean to one side when sleeping with a partner that’s larger than them
  • The Casper mattress leaves users susceptible to rolling off or causing premature wear due to a lack of sufficient edge support
  • Due to the way the mattress is packed for shipping, the Casper mattress can take up to 72 hours to fully expand

Warranty: Puffy vs Casper

In this section of our Puffy vs Casper comparison review, we’ll be going over the fine details of the warranties offered by both mattress companies.

 

Puffy Warranty

Pretty much every mattress company on the market offers some sort of warranty on their product if they don’t then it’s probably not worth packing home. But, you can usually only expect something around a 10-year limited warranty. Puffy has truly gone above and beyond when it comes to protecting your purchase.

They offer their customers a 101-night sleep trial period to use the mattress in your home and determine if it truly is the best fit for you. If you decide that it’s ultimately not your favorite, Puffy will coordinate to have the mattress donated to a local charity.

If you do decide to keep your mattress, your Puffy purchase is protected by a lifetime warranty. You read that right. Your mattress is warrantied for the entire time that you own it. The Puffy company will cover any defects in the material or workmanship. They are not responsible for any damages incurred from improper use and the warranty is only valid for the original purchaser.

Casper Warranty

The Casper company wanted to make sure that their customers had sufficient time to try their mattress out in their home and determine if it truly was the best mattress for their needs. That’s why they offer a 100-night sleep trial period. If you ultimately decide that Casper isn’t the mattress for you, the company will issue a full refund and even arrange to have the mattress picked up from your home.

If you do love your Casper and decide to keep it after the trial period is up, your purchase will remain protected by a 10-year limited warranty. The company will happily repair or replace the mattress at no cost to you if it’s found to have an indention of great than 1”, any malfunctions in the materials, or any defects in the zipper mechanism. Casper does not cover damages resulting from improper use, any Casper mattress purchased “as is”, or bought from an unauthorized dealer.

Who Wins?

When it comes to the warranties offered by the Casper vs Puffy companies, it’s pretty clear that Puffy takes the win. Both companies offer a pretty standard sleep trial period, but Puffy goes the extra mile by warrantying their product for the lifetime of your ownership.

About The Companies

To wrap up our Puffy vs Casper comparison review, we’ll be taking a look at a few of the most important details surrounding the mattress companies.

Puffy Company

The Puffy company is fairly new, only launching in 2017. The founders of the company wanted to create a high-quality, affordable mattress that felt just like sleeping on a cloud. They cut out the middleman and all the unnecessary and costly commissions and set out to provide customers with a cost-effective, straightforward, and comfortable mattress that will last them a lifetime.

The Puffy designers researched, tested, and sifted through tons of designs and materials before finally settling on what’s now known as the Puffy mattress. Every layer has been tried and tested, featuring Certi-PUR US Certified Foam to guarantee a truly cloud-like experience.

casper vs puffy mattress

Casper Company

Like so many mattress companies on the market these days, the Casper company was founded out of a desire for something better. The creators of the Casper mattress were disgruntled with the way folks were expected to buy a new mattress. The salesrooms were full of bright, fluorescent lights, the salesmen were pushy and ingenuine, and the prices were astronomical for products that weren’t even high quality.

All in all, the entire experience was uncomfortable and ineffective. So, in 2014 5 friends came together to rectify the problem once and for all. They cut out the big box store completely, reduced the costs, and did away with the salesmen and 10-second sleep trial. They created an online, direct-to-consumer mattress company that promised high-quality products, a significant in-home sleep trial period, and a price tag that was friendly to the average family.

Since their founding in 2014, the Casper mattress company has been recognized by Forbes, Good Morning America, and The New York Times. The company also received the title of one of the Most Innovative Companies by Fast Company in 2017 and received Good Housekeeping’s Lab Pick in 2018.

So, What’s The Final Conclusion Of Our Casper vs Puffy Comparison Review?

When it comes to Casper vs Puffy, this one was a tight race. Both mattresses are high-quality and offer fantastic temperature control, comfort, and support – all at a fairly average price.

But, we do always like to choose a winner. So, ultimately, Puffy takes the cake in our Puffy vs Casper comparison review. While the Puffy mattress does offer a more minimalistic approach to their construction and temperature control, they make sure that their mattress isn’t lacking. The adaptable foam guarantees complete comfort and support no matter your size or shape. And while they’re equipped with less temperature regulating properties than their Casper counterpart, users still claim that the Puffy mattress is super cool.

In the end, we feel that the Puffy mattress will certainly make good on its promise to give users a cloudlike experience for their rest of their life.

_________

See also: Puffy Mattress Review, Casper vs Tuft and Needle, Casper vs Leesa, Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding, Casper vs Ghostbed, and Casper vs Nectar.