Summary: This unbiased, in-depth review features the top 10 most comfortable mattresses our team of Sleeping Ninjas could find on the market.
Disclosure: Sleeping Ninjas has an affiliate relationship with some companies where we get a small percentage of sales if you click over from our site.
Can there really be a “most comfortable mattress” that appeals to everyone?
Well, no, not really. There are many factors involved that define the experience of comfort:
Your weight, your dominant sleeping position, your level of mobility, and your lifestyle are just some of the factors that come into play.
But, don’t worry. Our Sleeping Ninjas team has you covered. We analyzed over 90 mattresses to arrive at this top 10 list. And we’ll break each one down to help you hone in the most comfortable mattress that’s right for you.
Table of Contents
A Sneak Peek at Our Top Picks
Before we dive into the reviews, here’s a peek at our top 10 most comfortable mattresses for 2020:
Most Comfortable Mattress
The Winkbed is incredible durable with deep levels of back support. Excellent cooling abilities and ventilation. Euro top luxury feel.
Save $200 with NINJA200
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
The Helix Luxe is fully customizable to suit your needs with varying soft or firmness based on your sleeping style. Will not disappoint.
Save $200 with NINJA200
Most Comfortable Mattress
The Botanical Bliss latex-based, highly comfortable mattress with exceptional responsiveness and bounce. Isolates motion. Excellent heat distribution.
Save $100 with NINJA100
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
AS3 by Amerisleep provides superb comfort. Increases flow to provide a deeper sleep. Excellent pressure point relief and responsiveness.
Save $250 with NINJA250
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
The Oceano is made from superior materials. This eco-friendly, foam-based hybrid provides pressure point relief and cooling abilities with massive pillow top.
Save $175 with NINJA
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
Saatva provides a luxury, Euro-top feel. Excels at spinal support, joint pain relief, and breathability. Durable spring-based construction.
Save $100 (automatic)
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
DreamCloud also provides a luxury-style, padded feel. Cool. Contouring. Reduce your aches and pains. Very comfortable.
Save $200 with NINJA200
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
The BearHybrid provides superb luxury comfort. Industry-leading cooling technology. Highly adaptive. Excellent for active lifestyle.
Save 10% with NINJA10
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid is another highly comfortable mattress that offers patented cooling technology and contouring to adapt to your body.
Save 20% with NINJA20
MOST COMFORTABLE MATTRESS
Avocado Green is a Euro-style pillow top and luxury plush hybrid made from 100% organic materials. Excels at reducing pressure points and motion transfer.
Top 10 Most Comfortable Mattresses
Here they are again:
- The Winkbed
- Helix Lux
- Botanical Bliss
- Amerisleep AS3
- Oceano
- Saatva
- DreamCloud
- BearHybrid
- Brooklyn Aurora
- Avocado Green
(Scroll to the bottom for how we selected these top 10 most comfortable mattresses.)
Our Top 10 Most Comfortable Mattresses for 2020
Okay, now let’s dive in…
The WinkBed Luxury Hybrid
You’re going to find a finer, luxury-style hybrid mattress than The WinkBed. WinkBed mattresses are handmade to order in Wisconsin using only high quality, American-sourced materials.
The WinkBed utilizes a combination of deep support springs, stabilizing gel foam, and additional foam “Lumbarlayer” to create an unmatched sleeping experience. The mattress is designed specifically to reduce pressure points and provide exceptional lumbar support. The WinkBed also excels at ventilation, keeping you cool throughout the night.
Features
- Available in Softer, Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus firmness
- Euro-pillow top with gel-infused foam
- Incredible durable construction (no sagging)
- Excellent lumbar support and pressure point relief
- Strong edge support for those who sleep close to the edge
- Sleep exceptionally cool
- Full replacement lifetime warranty
- 120-night sleep trial
Recommended for
- Hot sleepers
- Sleepers with back pain
- Heavy-weight sleepers
- Back sleepers, side sleepers, stomach sleepers
- Everyday sleepers who want a super-comfortable sleep
The Bottom Line
The WinkBed Luxury Hybrid is easily one of the top 10 most comfortable mattresses on the market, combining excellent support, pressure relief, cooling capacity, and durability.
Save $200 on The Winkbed with code NINJA200
The Helix LUXE Mattress
The Helix team realized everyone is a little bit different. Are you a side sleeper? Back sleeper? Stomach sleeper? Want a firm feel? Or maybe something on the softer side? Whatever it is, Helix has you covered.
Helix customizes your mattress according to your requirements and individual preferences. You start by taking their Sleep Quiz and then they serve up your ideal mattress.
In general, like the Winkbed, Helix has raving fan customers. Their LUXE edition offers zoned lumbar support coils, a premium quilted pillow top, and a breathable Tencel cover. You’ll also get layers of memory foam, gel Visco, and two more layers of foam. It’s also OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified to have no harmful chemicals.
Features
- The most customizable mattress on the market
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified
- Keeps you cool
- Zoned lumbar support
- Hotel-style, quilted pillow top
- 15-year warranty
- 100-night sleep trial
Recommended for
- Back sleepers, side sleepers, stomach sleepers
- Everyday sleepers – just take the sleep quiz and find the right mattress for you
- Budget shoppers
- Hot sleepers
Not Recommended for
- Sleepers looking for a traditional “sinking in” memory foam feel
The Bottom Line
The customization feature that Helix offers is something that should be more common! There’s a reason Helix is a highly popular mattress.
Save $200 on Helix Mattresses with code NINJA200
The Botanical Bliss Organic Latex Mattress
The eco-friendly Botanical Bliss by Plushbeds has found its way onto numerous “best of” reviews here on Sleeping Ninjas. The Botanical Bliss is made of 100% natural latex—no coils or memory foam. We cover this in more detail in the buyer’s guide below, but compared to foam, latex has more bounce and responsiveness.
While many foam mattresses give you the feeling of sleeping “in” the mattress, latex-based mattresses give you the feeling of sleeping “on” it. A GOTS certified New Zealand Wool layer helps improve breathability and temperature regulation. And a breathable organic cotton cover also improves airflow and moisture absorption.
Features
- Comes in Medium and Medium-Firm options
- Height options: 9, 10, or 12 inches
- Adjustable (by moving around one of the latex layers)
- GOTS certified cotton, wool, and latex
- Anti-microbial, mold, and mildew proof
- Sleeps cool and quiet
- Highly responsive
- 100-night sleep trial
- 25-year warranty
Recommended for
- Eco-friendly consumers
- Sleepers who prefer latex to memory foam
- All sleeping types and all weights
Not recommended for
- Sleepers who like a strong edge support
- Sleepers who prefer to sink into their mattress
The Bottom Line
If you prefer a responsive mattress made from all-natural materials that will last you a long time, Plushbed’s Botanical Bliss is an excellent choice. This mattress has over 1,300 5-star reviews as one of the most comfortable mattresses people have ever slept on.
Save $100 on Plushbeds Botanical Bliss with code NINJA100
Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress
Brentwood Home offers an excellent suite of mattresses designed for the socially-conscious community. Their Oceano mattress is their most popular option.
This memory foam-based hybrid mattress deploys responsive, individually-wrapped coils with 5 zones to support your hips, back, and shoulders. Another layer of 1,722 micro-coils provides even more responsiveness and comfort.
Several layers of cooling gel memory foam and cool air luxe foam provide pressure-point relief and give you that sinking and hugging feeling. The Euro top layer made from GOTS-certified organic wool and the plant-based Tencel cover will keep you cool as you sleep.
Features
- Medium-plush firmness
- GOTS-certified organic wool; GOTS organic cotton canvas base
- Over 3,100 pocketed coils for precise support and comfort
- Cooling memory foam and gel layers
- 25-year warranty
- 1-year sleep trial
Recommended for
- Hot sleepers
- Eco-conscious consumers
- Light sleepers
- Individuals with an active lifestyle
Not Recommended for
- Heavy-weight sleepers
- Stomach sleepers
- Sleepers wanting an ultra-soft firmness level
The Bottom Line
Oceano is one of our team’s favorite mattresses. It feels luxurious, is intelligently-designed from high-quality materials. If you’re looking for a medium-plush firmness, Oceano is definitely one of the most comfortable mattresses.
Save $175 on Oceano with code NINJA
Amerisleep AS3
Amerisleep makes five different mattresses: AS1 – AS5. The number rating corresponds to the firmness level where AS1 is the most firm and AS5 is their softest option.
Their AS3 model is their most popular model with a medium feel. Amerisleep is known for being a pure memory foam mattress, but the company recently began offering a hybrid version as well. Their Celliant cover helps promote increased blood flow for deeper sleep by reflecting your body’s heat back as infrared light. Multiple layers of Bio-Pur open-cell foam provides excellent pressure point relief and responsiveness.
Features
- FDA-determined Celliant technology
- Isolates motion exceptionally well
- More responsive than traditional memory foam
- Soothing pressure point relief
- 100-night sleep trial
- 20-year warranty
Recommended for
- Anyone who enjoys the cradling feeling of memory foam
- Physically active individuals (due to the Celliant material)
- Couples
- Lightweight sleepers (under about 220 pounds or less)
Not recommended for
- Hot sleepers (based on some reports, AS3 doesn’t cool as well as other mattresses, although the AS3 reportedly does a better job at it)
- Sleepers looking for a strong edge
The Bottom Line
Amerisleep’s AS3 is a highly reliable and ultra-comfortable mattress for the right sleepers.
Save $250 on Amerisleep with code NINJA250
Saatva Luxury Mattress
Saatva is another easy contender for the most comfortable mattress. This handcrafted hybrid construction with a Euro Pillow Top to provide a truly luxury feel. Saatva deploys a patented Spinal Zone active wire support and memory foam pressure-relief layer to reduce back and joint pain and provide optimal spinal support.
And unlike many memory-foam based mattresses, Saatva offers a dual perimeter edge support system, which is important if you like to sleep towards the edge of your mattress. Their 13-gauge support coils in the lower base help ensure excellent breathability and long-term durability.
Features
- Available in plush soft (3), luxury firm (5-7) and firm (8)
- Truly luxurious feel
- Organic cotton cover
- Handcrafted
- Superior support for chronic pain
- 120-night sleep trial
- 15-year warranty
Recommended for
- Every sleeper type (side, back, stomach, etc.)
- Those suffering from back pain and chronic joint pain
- Hot sleepers
Not recommended for
- Sound-sensitive sleepers (their coils can be noisier than other mattresses)
- Couples (doesn’t excels at isolating motion)
- Sleepers who prefer the sinking and hugging experience of memory foam
The Bottom Line
For the solo-sleeper looking for pressure point relief and sound sleep, Saatva is definitely one of the most comfortable mattresses.
Save $100 on Saatva by clicking the button above
DreamCloud Gel Memory Foam Mattress
The DreamCloud Mattress is a luxury hybrid model that gives you the feeling that you’re floating on a cloud (instead of sinking into one). It sleeps cool and is exceptionally breathable from its use of inner coils and a gel-infused foam top layer.
The DreamCloud also excels with relieving any achy pressure points you may have to help you improve your sleep. The gel memory foam is on top, while the heavier regular memory foam is in the middle. Once unpacked, you have to leave it for up to two days for the full shape to come out.
Features
- Luxury firm (6.5)
- Quilted Euro Top
- Extremely comfortable and breathable
- Affordably-priced luxury style
- 365-night sleep trial
- Lifetime warranty
Recommended for
- All sleeping types
- Hot sleepers
- Sleepers with chronic pain (back, neck, shoulder, or hip)
- Shoppers looking for a “luxury” style mattress
Not Recommended for
- Sleepers who prefer that “hugging” feeling that some other memory foam mattresses provide
The Bottom Line
If you suffer from body aches and pains, sleeping on a DreamCloud may soothe all those pains away while you sleep. It’s soft yet very supportive, which makes it a perfect choice for you or anyone searching for the most comfortable mattress.
Get $200 off on Dream Cloud with code NINJA200
The Bear Hybrid
The Bear Mattress is specially designed for a health-restoring and refreshing sleep that lasts through the night. This medium-firm hybrid mattress uses pressure-relieving memory foam and pocket coil system.
The Bear maximizes airflow to help keep you extra cool as you sleep. The memory foam and graphite gel make this mattress up to seven times cooler than the regular memory foam mattresses. And with a solid, core support and contouring pressure relief, the mattress will relieve those aching spots and help you recharge for the next day.
Bear mattresses have no less than four layers of premium foam inside a clinically-proven Celliant fiber cover. This serves to provide a healing sleep by enhancing the flow of blood and oxygen into your body. While many memory foam mattresses sag along the edges, Bear’s extra-strong quantum coils provide full edge-to-edge support.
Features
- Medium-firm mattress (6.3)
- Hand-quilted Celliant fiber top (promote physical recovery)
- Excellent airflow and cooling capability
- Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified
- 100-night sleep trial
- 20-year warranty
Recommended for:
- Individuals with active lifestyles
- Sleepers with body soreness
- Hot sleepers
- Couples
- Those who prefer more bounce and less conforming
Not recommended for:
- Individuals who want to sink into their mattress
- Heavy-weight sleepers (over 250 pounds)
The Bottom Line
If you live an active lifestyle and are looking for a cooling mattress that provides pressure point relief, this Bear mattress is one of our top picks for the most comfortable mattress.
Save 10% on Bear Mattresses with code NINJA10
Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid
Brooklyn Bedding has been around for over a decade, with six different mattresses under their brand. Their Brooklyn Aurora mattress is their most popular model. This high-quality hybrid comes in three firmness levels and features a patented CopperFlex foam that provides contouring support and targeted pressure relief. Their patented TitanCool technology is designed to moderate skin temperature to ensure you have a cooling sleep experience.
Brooklyn’s TitanFlex makes up the second layer with a 2-inch open-cell material that’s hyper-elastic and similar to latex in response. Brooklyn’s patent, however, makes it stronger and more durable than latex alone. The six innovative layers in total provide a supportive, comfortable sleep that contours beautifully with your body.
Features
- Three comfort levels (soft, medium, and firm)
- Resist to mold, mildew, and dust mites
- Excellent cooling technology
- Contouring and comfort
- 120-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
Recommend for
- Hot sleepers
- Couples
- Side and stomach sleepers
Not recommended for
- Those looking for a conforming memory foam mattress
- Heavy-weight sleepers over 250 pounds (unless you get the firm model)
- Sleepers who are sensitive to off-gassing smells. (Brooklyn mattresses are known for pro-longed off-gassing.)
The Bottom Line
Brooklyn’s Aurora is an ultra-comfortable hybrid mattress for most sleeping types as well as couples. Just be sure to select the right firmness level for you.
Save 20% on Brooklyn Bedding with code NINJA20
Avocado Green Organic Hybrid Mattress
Avocado Green has become a staff favorite here at Sleeping Ninjas. Not only is it made of 100% certified organic materials, but with their Euro-style button-tufted pillow-top version, it’s also one of the most comfortable mattresses available online.
Avocado Green is made with a 1,414 encased inner coils with 5 distinct zones and 100% natural Dunlop latex. This mattress excels at reducing motion transfer (so you won’t feel your partner moving). It also does an excellent job relieving back pain and supports proper alignment.
The certified organic wool adds extra cushion, provides exceptional cooling and acts as a natural fire retardant. A GOTS certified organic cotton, hand-tufted cover adds breathability and durability.
Features
- With their pillow-top option, this mattress rates a 6 on the Comfort scale (luxury plush)
- 100% GOTS and GOLS certified organic cotton, wool, and latex
- Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX® and Made Safe Certified as non-toxic
- Reduces motion transfer, provides back relief and keeps you cool.
- Carbon neutral production and shipping
- 25-year warranty
- 365-night sleep trial
Recommended for
- Sleepers with back, neck and hip pain
- Couples (good at isolating movement)
- All sleeping types (back, stomach, and side) if you get the pillow top
- Eco-friendly individuals
Not Recommended for
- Heavy-weight individuals over 250 pounds
- If you don’t opt for the pillow-top option, this mattress we don’t recommend this mattress for stomach sleepers
The Bottom Line
Simply put, Avocado Green is an awesome mattress. You won’t find a more comfortable mattress that’s 100% organic, chemical-free, and non-toxic. Be sure to upgrade to their Euro pillow top option.
Buyer’s Guide to the Most Comfortable Mattress
Okay, so now that we’ve reviewed our top 10 most comfortable mattresses, let’s have a closer look at what to look for.
What to Look For in the Most Comfortable Mattress
Mattress Construction and Materials Used
The most popular mattress construction is called hybrids. And almost all of the mattresses on our top 10 list are hybrids.
A hybrid essentially means that it’s combining at least two key materials in its construction, one of which is innerspring coils or encased coils. The other key material is usually some form of memory foam or latex.
Memory foam is used in the majority of comfortable mattresses. Memory foam provides that sinking and “hugging” feeling that many sleepers associate with a great mattress.
Latex, in contrast, provides more bounce and responsiveness. It’s really a matter of personal preference more than anything else. As a general rule, latex sleeps cooler than memory foam, but there are all kinds of cooling gel foam used in the above mattresses that provide the same cooling benefits.
Firmness level
The mattress industry uses a comfort scale from 1 to 10 where 1 is the softest and 10 is extra firm. Most mattresses fall within the medium-firm range between 5.5 and 7. You’ll see this range often referred to as “plush firm” or “luxury firm.”
The firmness level is an important factor when it comes to comfort. And your sleeping style largely dictates which firmness level will work best for you. (We’ll cover this in more detail below when we discuss sleeper positions.)
Motion transfer
Motion transfer refers to the mattress’s ability to absorb movement. This feature is especially relevant when you’re sleeping with a partner. A mattress with less motion transfer means that you’re not going to wake up every time your partner turns over in their sleep.
Warranty
Online mattress brands offer a wide range of warranties ranging from 10-year to lifetime warranties. Most warranties tend to fall between 10-year and 25-year.
Sleep Trial
It would be risky to make such an expensive purchase online without knowing for sure that you’ve found the most comfortable mattress for you. However, online mattress brands have eliminated this problem by offering sleep trials.
Sleep trials are like extended “money-back guarantee” periods. Sleep trials tend to range from 90 nights to a full year. This means you can purchase one of these mattresses, sleep on it for a few months, and if you decide it’s not for you, contact the manufacturer, and they’ll schedule a pickup. Most mattress brands offer free shipping as well as free returns.
Your Preferred Sleeping Position
Besides the mattress itself, the key factor to take into account is how you sleep. Are you a:
- Back sleeper,
- Side sleeper,
- Stomach sleeper, or
- Combination thereof.
Generally, back sleepers prefer a more firm mattress than stomach sleepers. However, those with hip, neck or back pain, prefer mattresses that cushion them and contour to their body (which is what memory foam excels at). Heavy-weight sleepers tend to prefer mattresses on the firm side of the scale.
Your Lifestyle
Finally, it’s important to keep your lifestyle and overall body state in mind. Are you highly active? We’ve found that active individuals prefer more bounce and responsiveness in their mattresses and tend to enjoy mattresses on the firmer side of the scale.
Are you experiencing chronic pain? Many of the most comfortable mattresses are designed specifically to ease pressure points and cradle and conform to your exact position, supporting your back, neck, and hips.
Remember that memory foam will conform more to your body than latex while latex is more responsive and provides greater bounce.
Conclusion: The Top 10 Most Comfortable Mattresses
Our team went through our database of over 90 mattresses to select which mattresses for this list. Each of the above mattresses can stand on its own; they are all known to be highly comfortable and have raving fan customers.
That said, be sure to read through customer reviews when you’re shopping for your mattress. We especially pay attention to the reviews with less than five stars to better understand where the mattress falls short for some sleepers. Even the highest-rated, most comfortable mattresses are not right for everyone.
Enjoy your new mattress, whichever you decide!